Michelle—December 19, 2025
Wow! Is all I can say about my new 1.5 crt earrings. I had initially purchased 0.86 crt diamond earrings and decided they were too small. I was going to order the 1 crt but then I came across these 1.5 crt diamond earrings in the Martin setting. I was hesitant because I didn’t want them to look to big in my small ears. They are stunning! The 14krt Gold is beautifully polished with a gorgeous shine to it. The diamonds shine from all the way across the room. They are full of sparkles. The backs of the earrings are push on and have a snug fit on them. I feel the weight of the .75 each ear is the perfect size if you want it to be noticed without being “ extra” over the top. It does feel like it droops a bit on my ear but I think it’s just me getting used to a bigger size stud than I am used too. You truly can not go wrong if you want .75 of dazzle in each earlobe. I’m obsessed. Read more
Ariel Watts—December 24, 2025
These earrings are so darling! And the sparkle is insane. I haven't had them long, but they are absolutely stunning in my ears, and the double-click closure makes them feel very secure in my ears. I got the 2ctw, so each earring is 1 carat, and that feels like the perfect size without going overboard. Read more
Heather Drake—December 8, 2025
I was nervous about purchasing an expensive piece of jewelry on amazon(not gold plated/cubic zirconia pricing). Absolutely stunning jewelry. I purchased a 2 and 3 ct pair of martini set studs both equally beautiful. I kept the larger pair although I agree with other reviewers, the 2ct are plenty large enough. Once I tried the 3ct I just wanted them. The packaging was substantially nicer than other brands on amazon and came with a grading card. The cut color and clarity far exceeded my expectations with both pairs of earrings. I purchase a large amount of jewelry and browse the selection of the seller regularly now hoping for a new listing. I would purchase from them again in a heartbeat. Ive worn them daily and do wish they had a screw back to support the weight. The earrings do sit perfectly and close to the ear because of the martini prong setting but the weight does cause them to nearly pull out. Just something to consider. Overall id purchase again with the thought in mind that you have to be conscious of checking the backings if you were them daily. Read more
Darrell A Martin—June 13, 2024
The product is quite a remarkable piece of jewelry. You can absolutely feel the quality of the metals and see the brilliance and dances of light in each stone: I promise you, when you get these earrings, your heart will skip a beat - when you put them on for the first time, and for me, every time since, you can feel the effortless weight of pure beauty. The stones are so stunning: indoors it is one of the most sparkling pieces of jewelry - you will be the envy of the room. Outdoors the stones shine and bounce radiant, vibrant rainbow flashes - it’s hypnotizing. it is why I insisted on solving the missing certificate issue. none of that matters if after sales customer service is non-existent, or at the very least, not responsive.[UPDATE: I reached a representative and we have solved the issue. The certificate was located in the provided pouch. Note: the certificate is the size of a credit card- this is how I missed it as it was unintentionally hidden in the pouch. Double check the pouch and the box itself to be sure your certificate is missing.] I have sent two emails, and spent 40 minutes with 5 different Amazon associates in a failed and foolhardy attempt to rectify my issue - let me assure you[UPDATED it is FINALLY resolved.] I thought my order was missing the IGI certificate as my jewelry piece is certified. Sounds simple enough to solve: issue the certificate for the jewelry based on laser etched serial numbers in the stones visible under 10x magnification - yet…. Apparently, not.[UPDATED - “since certificates that are issued are specific to each pair of stones, re-issue is not possible” per my contact with customer care representative. However, Not even Amazon has a way to contact Carbon Atelier. Until this issue is resolved, for me, the rating will remain at 1-star. Something tells me this may have been a one off issue[UPDATE: turns out, sometimes the IGI certificates can get lodged in the box lids, and flaps. In my case mines was placed in the provided pouch. The certificate is indeed the size of a credit card, so it did not extend out of the pouch. On the suggestion of customer care, I fished through my recycling to find the original box and luckily I discovered the certificate.]but it’s[UPDATED: IT WAS] - the lack of handling that I just can’t bare to see go unchecked. There’s got to be a better way. Signed- disappointed, disillusioned, and dissatisfied. Now signed: a satisfied and now repeat customer. I was NOT compensated for this review, I am NOT affiliated with Carbon Atelier in any way other than a paying customer. I was NOT influenced in any way to alter this review my Carbon Atelier. Read more
Kevin Moore—September 20, 2024
For the price and the clarity rating I didn't expect much I knew they should be probably very nice but they were much better than nice, they were stunning. The clarity, size and backings were great but there was one thing wrong one of the posts were slightly bent but definitely noticeable. Thankfully it didn't take much to straighten it out and now they're everything I hope that they would be. Read more
Customer—December 25, 2025
Beautiful sparkly diamonds Read more
Dayen Glez—August 21, 2024
The media could not be loaded. Absolutely beautiful diamond studs and incredible value for money. I was in the market for a pair of diamond studs, and I came across these on Amazon and couldn't believe the price, so I decided to try them. They were shipped quickly, and I was surprised to see how big they look; I was expecting them to be smaller, so I'm adjusting to their size currently. I recommend that if you have small to medium proportions, go with the smaller size since 2ct looks big (in my opinion). Overall, I am very happy with this purchase! Thank you!!! Read more
Manuel Vazquez—December 29, 2025
Girlfriend loved them Read more