COVERGIRL Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner Eyeliner Pencil - Toffee 230mg 0 008 oz

Excellent eyeliner, way better than I remember! I used this years ago and didn't like it because it didn't go on smooth but took a chance because of the price and im so glad I did because its amazing goes on so smooth and effortlessly, isn't smudgy and is bold. Plus has the eraser which is a must for me! Read more

I have used this eyeliner, mostly Black Onyx, for many, many years! It is definitely my go-to product. Before online shopping I would be so upset when the stores would be out of this and I would be forced to use something else. I would always just toss those as soon as I was able to get my hands on this stuff! I love how easily it applies and the built-in smudger. I only have a couple of small points to make about these. First, it says "self-sharpening" but it does not actually sharpen the point. It is just that the surface area is small so it allows for more precise application. Unlike a traditional pencil eyeliner where the surface gets wider as the tip wears down so you need to sharpen it to get the pointed tip back, this always is a "tip" so no need to sharpen. Second, as I said, I have used this product for many, many years. Occasionally, I will receive one of these where the crayon is broken inside the cover, usually into many small pieces. It means that, as applying, the piece will just fall off. It's annoying, messy, and wasteful. But, that being said, it only happens very occasionally. Overall, I still love this eyeliner and I will continue to purchase it! Read more

This eyeliner is great! It lasts clear till the next day if you need it to. Or it comes off nicely at night just like it should. The texture is fine. Its a soft line. Not a hard line. I love this eyeliner because it stays in place when I cry. Or sweat. Highly recommend! Read more

Good for the money but does smear and doesn't last all day. Nice for an inexpensive eyeliner. Easy to apply and goes on smooth. Read more

For my personal makeup style, this is my favorite eyeliner I've tried. I like to do an eyeliner that looks natural - so the dark coffee color and the soft edges you can achieve are great for me, but also, I'm still able to make enough of a little pointed wing (I use my fingernail to drag out the end and "sharpen" the drawn wing shape). It doesn't erase over the course of a day for me. I personally don't much use more bold, opaque, super sharp-edged, graphic liner, which some other eyeliner pencils (like Clio) or liquid ones (Wet and Wild, Nyx) can achieve, so if you prefer that sort of look, this product might not be your go-to. Read more

Best eyeliner I’ve used. Glides on smoothly. Apply light or heavy. The sponge tip is great for smoothing color, softening the line and a smoky effect. Stays all day, washes off with soap and water. Read more

I've been using this eyeliner for many years. Lately, I can't find it in the stores around here. Goes on nice and easy and isn't harsh looking liquid liners. Read more

Starts smearing pretty quickly. Have to constantly touch up your corners so it doesn't look like you're crying or something Read more