You never know how comfortable a shoe is just by looking at it and I was quite pleasantly surprised when this pair arrived! They're a soft suede and although I could've fit into a half size down, I think the 8.5 was a better choice. I could probably put an insole in them (I love a cushiony insole). They're made well and are very comfortable to walk in too. It's quite versatile and can be worn with jeans, slacks or even a skirt. I'm super excited to wear them this fall and know I'll get a lot of use out of them too...I think they'll become a wardrobe staple, and I definitely recommend them. Read more