Last year, I bought these boots in size 9 (my usual Frye boot size) in the "sunrise" color. I was very disappointed that the fit was too tight and the leather too stiff, and assumed that a 9.5 would be too large, so I reluctantly returned them. Recently, I decided I would try the 9.5, anyway, but in "burnt red." PERFECT. The leather is supple, and I can wear them with or without inserts. I was worried that the heel might be too high for comfort (all my other boots have heels of 2" or less), but that's not at all the case. These boots are incredibly well made (in the USA), extremely comfortable, and just adorable (added bonus: they make your feet look small!). Kind of a pain to put on, since there's no side zipper, so you have to deal with loosening and tightening the shoestrings, but that's not a big deal for me. Couldn't be happier. P.S.: Re the conflicting reviews on these boots' stiffness and break-in time: the pebbled options are softer and require virtually no break-in time. Also, it's important to know that boot sizes, in general, are a half-size smaller than street shoe sizes. For example, I invariably wear a 9.5 in street shoes (oxfords, loafers, etc.) and a 9 in boots. So, while I needed to go up to a 9.5 for this style (probably because of my high instep), I almost always comfortably wear a 9 in Frye boots (engineer, Veronica, etc.). Read more
Absolutely LOVE these boots. I've always loved Frye in general but these are my absolute favorites. Very versatile and super cute. They are quality made and have that lovely leather smell! Mmmm... They are a little stiff to start with but that shouldn't be a surprise. They are heavy quality leather and built to last. After the first wearing they were pretty well broke in and comfy despite the heavier leather. Frye tends to run a little narrow but they are already good to go. They have perfect style too. they are "rugged" but the heal keeps them from being too clunky. You can dress them up or down. I really like the rubber bottom. Some Frye boots are leather soled and therefore very slippery. These are not. If you buy these you will not regret it! Read more
Oh, these boots are exquisite!!! SO well made and the leather is gorgeous. I take a size 7.5 in shoes and boots, but initially ordered the 8 because I am an 8 in the Sabrina 14L. However, I had to exchange them for the 7.5, so for me they run true to size. They are very comfortable and the Sunrise color is wonderful - I was worried that it would look too orange, but it doesn't, it's simply beautiful. The grey is beautiful also - that was the color I got in size 8. I think these are a great price for the quality and I'm thrilled with them!!! Read more
I love the style and the heel of these Frye boots—they have a classic, high-quality look that pairs well with everything. The leather feels premium, and the craftsmanship is mostly great. Unfortunately, the pair I received has a defect: a quarter-sized raised area/protrusion on the toe of the left boot. It’s disappointing because everything else about them is perfect. If not for the flaw, they’d be five stars. I’m hoping this was just a one-off issue because Frye is known for its quality. It’s extremely disappointing that the company hasn’t reached out at all. I expected more for a $400 pair of boots. Read more
I ordered these boots to wear to my wedding next week. I’ve spent a while trying to find a pair of boots that would be bridal, comfortable, and easy to hike in, so I was really, really excited to finally find these. I already own them in another color so I was confident they would be perfect for my day. They arrived pretty quickly and are absolutely gorgeous, but they are totally unwearable because they are two completely different sizes. One boot is a 7.5 and the other is an 8.5. So not only did I waste hundreds of dollars and a lot of time, but now I don’t have shoes to wear to my wedding. Regardless of the price of boots or occasion you’re buying them for, it’s a pretty reasonable expectation to get a matched pair. Instead, I have half of what I ordered and half of some other pair of boots. *UPDATE* the seller did overnight me the missing 7.5 boot, so now I have more than a complete pair. They were cool about it and immediately fixed the issue, which hey, that’s the best you can really ever hope for and I have shoes for my wedding which is also pretty cool. If you’re thinking about buying these boots, definitely try to just find them in person so you can make sure you’re actually getting a pair that match instead whichever two vaguely similar shoes the seller can find to throw together. But if you can’t find them in person, and if you do get two vaguely similar shoes, they will fix the issue, so you’ll have an identical pair, a third wheel shoe, and a funny story. As far as fit goes, they’re narrow and if you have a high instep or a wide foot you may find them a little uncomfortable if you don’t size up a bit. They can be especially tight around the top and sides of the mid foot area because of how they’re stitched together (there are seams by the tongue/bottom of the laces) so that’s an area where you’ve ever had shoe tightness before, sizing up would be a good idea. You have to loosen the laces pretty much all the way to put them on, but they’re comfortable and sturdy once you’re actually in them. The tread is good so you’re probably not going to slip and fall walking around on most reasonable conditions. They also make you look like you have tiny little doll feet which is weird but feels worth mentioning. Read more
I was clearly sent used boots even though the description said new. I didn't try them on because I felt mislead and frankly grossed out by it. I'm disappointed because I've wanted these boots for a long time and I'm not able to find them in new condition in my size anywhere. They are cute in person and the other Frye boots I've owned in the past are excellent quality. I'd recommend purchasing them but do your research on seller and condition beforehand! Read more
