Les Mis rables

I loved everything about this movie except for Russell Crowe, who had no business at all being in it. His acting was mediocre and his singing abysmal. The rest of the cast, though, was amazing. Hugh Jackman - He did a fabulous job as Jean Valjean! Some people have criticized his singing, but I disagree. It had an edge to it that really played well into Valjean's character and he made the role come alive. I think Hugh Jackman as Valjean *might* surpass Hugh Jackman as Wolverine (well, maybe not THAT far...) Anne Hathaway - She deserved that Oscar. All I can say is AMAZING!!! Amanda Seyfried - Her acting was great and I completely respect her for getting a voice double to handle her songs. A great decision that was best for the movie. She was a high soprano with a voice like a bell--perfect for the role. Sasha Baren Cohen & Helena Bonham Carter - They did a good job at being despicable in a comic relief sort of way. Which is too bad, really. While they were scummy, they failed to be truly evil. Even when Bonham Carter was threatening abuse against the child Cosette, she didn't come across as intimidating or even very dark. Same when Baren Cohen brought a bunch of thugs to rob and possibly murder Valjean. He just didn't pull off the darkness. Still, they did their roles well overall. That-guy-who-played-Marius: Great job! He really gave Marius a personality that I had trouble getting from the play and gave him a true place in the story. His voice was great, and I was blown away by his performance in "Empty Chairs at Empty Tables". The direction wasn't the best, but he was at his best. That-gal-who-played-Eponine: AMAZING! She really understood Eponine and all the details that made her who she was. The way she emotionally rose and fell at each interaction with Marius was subtle, but perfect. And when she sang On My Own, she had a moment there that just about moved me to tears. Colm Wilkinson (the Bishop of Digny): I was so pleased to see him in the movie. Colm was the original Broadway Valjean and the decision to include him as Father Bienvenue, the Bishop of Digny, was beautiful. It seemed like a little thing, but as a longtime fan of the play, it means a LOT. Russell Crowe: What can I say. He should NOT have been in this movie. He was like the aftertaste of a pill you had in your mouth for too long before swallowing. His singing sounded like someone trying to talk while yawning and his voice and acting lacked the passion, conviction, and wholehearted devotion to the play that everyone around him seemed to have. I wish his suicide in the movie would have been 2 hours earlier so we could be done with him. Regardless of his lack of singing and acting ability in the movie (don't get me wrong, I LOVE Gladiator, liked Master and Commander, and liked A Beautiful Mind) this is an absolute MUST SEE. Read more

I'm twenty-seven years late to Les Miserables, the musical. I'll admit it. I wasn't interested until the movie was getting press. It looked really cool, and the likelihood of me ever seeing it on stage seemed slim and not something I really, hugely wanted. So I went with my friend, who'd already seen the stage show and the movie (she went before I did). I can honestly say that there are three narratives that have altered the course of my life, and they're the Lord of the Rings, Supernatural, and now, most recently, Les Mis. As a rule, I don't do tragedy. I don't do stories where everybody dies. I refuse to do Titanic for that very reason. But dear god, am I glad that I made the exception for this one. The Movie is an enormous, beautiful mix of the fantastic musical with snippets of canon from the book thrown in. Bahorel's back, though he never made the musical, Enjolras and Grantaire die side-by-side as in the brick, and nobody's quite as romanticized by the movie as they are by the musical, and I love it. I couldn't have asked for a better introduction. Russell Crowe will always be my Javert, for example. He brings a depth to the man that can't be done on stage. I love stage!Javert, I do -- Norm Lewis is fantastic and rigid as iron in the 25th anniversary special, for example -- but Crowe, Crowe gives me a sadder Javert, a Javert who is falling even before he seems to realize it himself. And he is /gentler/, too; when he tells Fantine, "I have heard such protestations/Every day for twenty years/Let's have no more explanations/Save your breath, save your tears," he almost seems to pity her. Stage!Javert, on the other hand, is often openly disdainful with these lines, often emphasizing that last word as though the idea of the "whore" crying sickens him because she is a criminal and in his eyes deserves it and should take it without weeping, I don't mourn stage-Javert, I pity him. But Crowe's Javert made me hurt for him, and he remains one of my favorite parts of the movie. Anne Hathaway may not be the most vocally powerful Fantine we've ever had, but the starkness of Fantine's plight makes for brilliant cinema in ways that, again, the stage show can't. Reordering "I Dreamed a Dream" to come after "Lovely Ladies" is an inspired choice, because it renders the song to be part of the very lowest, darkest point in Fantine's tragedy. Moving forward, the "barricade boys" are absolutely brilliant. With Killian Donnelly (a former Enjolras on stage) as Combeferre and Broadway star Aaron Tveit as Enjolras, we're in very good hands for Les Amis de l'ABC. Tveit brings a brilliant physicality to the part of Enjolras, and his facing his mortality in "Drink With Me" (which, unfortunately enough, cuts out Grantaire's fairly pivotal verse to that effect) with nothing more than a few sorrowful looks is absolutely brilliant. I love Enjolras more than practically any other fictional character, and Tveit is one of my favorite people who've played him. Many of the barricade boys are even better upon rewatching -- I didn't fall in love with Combeferre until my third viewing, when I realized how much he loves the rest of the Amis, how willing he is to take care of all of them in his way. He's their arsenal (alluded to when he is double-wielding pistols on the barricade) and their guide and dies with a comforting hand on Joly's arm. Feuilly is also wonderful, and the friendship between Courfeyrac and Gavroche is absolutely heartbreaking, with Courf sobbing openly when Gavroche is murdered. But most understated and most beautiful, I think, is George Blagden as Grantaire, the group's cynic and drunk. As I mentioned before, Grantaire's verse in "Drink With Me" was cut, which is a pretty major piece of characterization for both him and for, in many stage productions, his dynamic with Enjolras. In the brick, it's stated flat out that Grantaire worships Enjolras, and Blagden's Grantaire makes it clear with every movement, every glance, from beginning to end. He captures the essence of the cynic with only one thing to believe in, and I could write reams of analysis on the subject. Cinematically, the film is almost perfect. The only issue I had is the overuse of background blurring in "Empty Chairs at Empty Tables." But that's literally, along with the missing DWM verse, the only flaw in the movie. I'm a film major, and I can only dream of ever making a movie this perfect, and this apropos to the time it's been released. You see, we're, globally, in a time of intense political, economic, and social upheaval. We, in the US specifically, are a culture in flux. A culture due, I think, for a few revolutions. Without Les Mis, I wouldn't have become nearly as passionate for change as I am, and I certainly wouldn't have sat down and decided to read a book with 2600 pages in it for fun and then proceed to start a project where I give my summer to Enlightenment-through-post-1848 political discourse. Les Mis opened me up to a whole new universe of possibility for my future, and I think it has for a lot of its new fans, even though it's so solidly set in the past. I have to call forth the final lines of "Finale," here -- "Will you join in our crusade?/Who will be strong and stand with me?/Somewhere beyond the barricade/is there a world you long to see?/Do you hear the people sing?/Say do you hear the distant drums?/It is the future that we bring when tomorrow comes!" The story asks us to look at the world around us. And, when we find it wanting, stand up and do something about it. And that's a message I can throw myself behind wholeheartedly. The future doesn't just come; we make it, we shape it into what it is -- that's the whole point, in the end, of the story. With love, and because of love, we are strong enough to fight for the future we want and deserve. Maybe we'll fail. Maybe we'll only have reward in Heaven. And maybe we'll succeed. But we'll never know which if we never try. Read more