This eyeliner may be waterproof but its not the type of waterproof that will make you rub your face raw with a bunch of different products trying to get it off. It stays on all day, hell I have cried, slept and went swimming with it on and this stuff STAYED PUT. (I will say for the swimming aspect, she did start to come off after 2 hours being mostly submerged but that's still amazing) no streaks at all. I have been veering away from felt tip liners because I feel I cannot be as precise as I would like to be. This changed the game for felt tip liners. It has has the ability to be ultra precise and also thick if need be. Application is the easiest with absolutely no streaking, feathering, smudging or bleeding. Read more
This is my favorite eyeliner, hands down! I love the tip. It works like a paintbrush but it's foam, so you don't have little strands of the brush making erroneous marks. I used to use the hyper easy eyeliner, and the little hairs on the brush would get caught on the tube when I put the wand back in. Then when I'd use it, it would have some hairs sticking out to the side and get extra marks on my eyelids. This tip avoids that problem but is flexible. It is just as dark as the other brush tip eyeliners, which is much darker than the pencil ones. It's also pointed at the end and makes a precision line. I like to do the cat eye look and it's perfect for that. I also like that it lasts a really long time. I've had the same one for at least 6 months and it's just now needing to be replaced. Just a heads up, though--the listing says waterproof, but it doesn't say that anywhere on the package or tube, and it sure doesn't seem waterproof. If my eyes start watering, the corners come off and smudge against my eyelids. The rest of it will be fine, but the corners always smear when wet. This seems to be more true for tears than water, though. Humidity doesn't do much, just my eyes watering or sweating. For me, the ease of application and length of use makes it worth that little annoyance. And anyway, waterproof makeup has forever plastics (pfas) in it, so I'm happy if this doesn't. Read more
This eyeliner is everything you could ask for. Value, quality and exceeded my expectations. It glides on so smooth and it is very pigmented and makes my eyes stand out. I will definitely order again and again. Read more
y3kserge's lady: Listen, if you’re looking for a liquid liner that gives you that crispy, clean cat eye with one swipe - this one? She delivers. The felt tip is precise (hence the name), and it’s black-black, not that weird grey-black some liners try to pass off as "intense." Absolutely no skipping or dragging, and I can get my wings even without caffeine - a miracle. BUT. Let’s talk real talk: if you have oily eyelids like I do, she might smudge. Not always, but enough that I started setting my eyelids with powder before applying this, and I don’t blink aggressively until it dries. So yeah, waterproof-ish, but oily-lid-proof? Not quite. Still, for the price and the performance, I’m not mad about it. Pro tip: Do the Subscribe & Save every 2–3 months to keep it fresh. These pens don’t last forever, and a dried-out liner is just heartbreak in tube form. I keep the old ones for creative makeup looks or smudgy liner days - waste not, want not. Final verdict? If your lids lean Sahara, you’re golden. If they lean frying pan like mine - prep and set, queen. Either way, this little pen’s staying in my makeup bag. Read more
I started my shift at 0700 and this pic was taken at 1700 (5pm). It lasted all day. My eyes tend to water so I need something that wouldn't smudge. It goes on smoothly. I love it. Read more
Shipping was good, product. Not a fan. I love Maybeline and use Maybeline for All eye products but this is a miss for me. It says waterproof, hmmm, so if you apply it, let it dry, splash with water, yes it doesnt run, BUT..... if you touch at all while your eye is wet. It will run all over. Also, smuges off very easily. This eyeliner does not stay on my eyes long. After a couple of hours, it already wearing off, even if I'm not touching but its hard to not touch my eyes. I always use a Maybeline waterproof liquid eyeliner with felt tip that doesn't smear and stays on all day and all night. Can't believe same company makes this product. I wouldn't buy again. It does glide on easily and the tip is good on controlling where you place it. I just don't like the formula. Read more
I’m genuinely impressed with this eyeliner! The pigmentation is rich and intense — one swipe gives a bold, deep color that lasts all day without fading. Whether I’m going for a soft daytime look or a dramatic winged liner for a night out, this product delivers every time Read more
THE BEST EYELINER IN THE GAME! BEST PIGMENT EASY TO USE! MAKES PERCISE LINES ILL NEBER USE ANOTHER! Read more
