Revlon Colorstay Eyeliner Black Pack Of 14

This was my favorite eyeliner until they changed the formula. It seems like you have to go over the line a few times to make it look darker. Read more

For the price, this product stays on quite well all day and is easy to use. Withstands tears well. While not having to use a sharpener makes it quick to use, it also means the point is dull unless you use the small, awkward sharpener built in the end. So you end up using it dull or end up using the sharpener which defeats the no sharpener appeal. Would like someone to invent the self sharpening eyeliner that also keeps a sharp point. Read more

Revlon Colorstay may be a good eyeliner on the lashline, but it definitely does not stay on the waterline, which is where I like to use eyeliner. It seems to just disappear after about an hour. I will say that it is easy to apply & remove and goes on smoothly. Read more