“We Are What They Grow Beyond.”
Phenomenal. Between The Force Awakens and The Last Jedi, Disney has succeeded in making Star Wars fun again. Where the prequels were meandering and senseless (with a soupçon of ill-advised “comic relief” flatulence/poop jokes), the new films are well structured and build to satisfying conclusions, with humor that doesn’t undercut the tone. SLIGHT SPOILER ALERT “TFA” and “TLJ” are about change and new beginnings. We are slowly but surely saying goodbye to the Skywalker family; George Lucas’ silly vision of Anakin, etc. as THE ONLY PEOPLE THAT MATTER IN THE WHOLE GALAXY has been retired in favor of a vision of a more democratic version of the Force, not contingent on the number of bugs in your bloodstream. Why? The Jedi Order looks ridiculous under the weight of Lucas’ prequels, Clone Wars cartoons, and his expanded universe. While the original trilogy gives a sense of a small but dedicated order of spiritual warriors, Lucas later transformed them into a massive order of celibate warrior monks and bodyguards, answerable to no one but an inept council that has no foresight and delivers intentional slights to its own members on a whim. Many have commented on how the Jedi Council seems to act only in service of propelling the plot, without any identifiable “in-universe” reason. Example: Anakin is elevated to the Council but spuriously denied the title of Master. We are not given a real reason, except for the fact that we know Anakin needs to feel betrayed by the Jedi so he can have the motivation to turn against them. If the council thought for a moment, they would instead deny Anakin a spot on the Council altogether under the argument that he was not ready yet, or they could just elevate him to full Master status and overrule him when he allowed his emotions to get the better of him. Either option may have failed to mollify him completely, but might have avoided his turn to the Dark Side, which was precisely what they wanted to prevent in the first place! In contrast, the characters in the new films are fresh and unencumbered by the lore of Star Wars. It’s nice to see strong women in these films; my two-year-old daughter will one day be able to see Rey as the hero of Star Wars movies, something that would have been unthinkable ten years ago. Likewise, although there are callbacks to the original trilogy, these new films are clearly forging their own path, so to speak. The death of Snoke was surprising and satisfying; in three seconds, the dynamic of the entire trilogy was permanently altered. Kyle Ren’s inner conflict and ultimate embrace of the Dark Side (while simultaneously rejecting Snoke’s teachings about the Dark and the Light) was suspenseful and well done. And sad as it was to see Luke die, it was necessary for the films to move forward (and not entirely unexpected on my part). And of course, how could I not mention the return of Yoda to confront Luke about his indecision and doubts, to remind him that failure is the greatest teacher, and to remind us that Luke, whose mind is never on where he is or what he is doing, is not perfect. And that last image of Luke, older and wiser, watching two suns set, is poignant and perfect. Some criticism has been leveled at the “new” force powers, like astral projection and telepathy. Are these new, though? If the Jedi can control the minds and thoughts of others, why can force-sensitive individuals not communicate telepathically? Luke and Darth Vader did just that in “Empire” (“Luke...” “Father?”). And if Jedi can become Force ghosts after death, why can’t they project an image of themselves across space? The truth is, “The Force” is whatever the writers say it is, like it or not. All in all, I found The Last Jedi to be satisfying. Rey found a new way that rejects the dogma of the Jedi order (much like Leto’s Golden Path in “God Emperor of Dune” rejected the dogma of Muad’Dib’s religion and the restrictions of the Bene Geserit sisterhood), Kylo Ren fulfilled the destiny of a Sith Lord by killing his master before rejecting the Sith, the Resistance created new heroes, and we saw Leia get a proper send off (“No one is ever truly gone,”). Don’t listen to the naysayers; the special effects are fantastic, the characters change and grow, and the story moves forward. Read more
















