Anthony S—December 31, 2025
I am somewhat of a soap snob and don't buy soaps from large corporations. Typically I go to specialty shops for soaps but I saw this on Amazon and decided to give it a try. Alls I have to say is wow! This soap is great! It is scented just right and it lathers up really nicely! It is also a great value for your money! At only about $4 a bar, I was expecting the soap bars to be small but they are large. Its great for skin cleanliness and the texture is great. I think I will be buying this soap going forward. I should be surprised though because when the Amish do something, they do it right! I rarely leave reviews on Amazon but had to for this product. I would highly recommend it to family and friends. Read more
Susan Laurito—December 26, 2025
This is the best bar soap I have come across in a long time. It makes a lot of soapsuds, does not dry out your skin and the scent is so pleasant. Very good quality. Read more
Ruth McDonald—December 29, 2025
I gave it some time before I wrote my review because I wanted to make sure the soap didn't dry out my skin (it did NOT). The smell is fresh and wonderful. The bars are big and produce lots of easy lather. You feel clean and fresh after using it. The fact you get 5 huge bars for 15 dollars is pretty amazing. It has good ingredients too, not lots of weird fillers. Love it! Read more
Vickie Loafman—December 20, 2025
I love this soap so much !!!!! I had a friend recommend it to me! The first time I tried it I loved how it lathered up on my hair !! Great Shampoo Bar !!!!! It rinses out clean and made my hair feel like it hadn't in a long time - it was soft and manageable !! I highly recommend this soap --- also my main reason for buying is that I was looking for a CLEAN ingredient hair shampoo bar !! This one is perfect !! Read more
Lotsofkids Sendhelp—July 31, 2025
I bought this soap and also a pack of Dove Restoring bar soaps- just trying to find something better and experiment. I was more excited about this Amish soap, and each family member has a different bar. It really DOES leave my skin so soft and is really good for using on my face- my rosacea really chilled out a lot and it leaves skin super clean but not that kind of squeaky clean that makes you wonder if you just stripped every bit of oil and moisture from your skin. The smell is nice, I don’t really notice it after drying off but the benefits way outweigh that negative for me. THIS IS THE WEIRD PART, hear me out. I had never smelled anything like this soap before. It is a very distinct smell, and on opening the bag, I thought all the soaps smelled the same and were just different colors. This evening, I got a wild hair and decided to try out one of the Dove Restoring bars. IMMEDIATELY when I opened the package, I was SHOOK TO DEATH that it smelled EXACTLY like the Amish bar I had been using! When I got in the shower, I compared the two- and it was the exact same scent. Then I smelled the bars I had given to the rest of my family and noticed they all smelled different after having been used a few times. Noticeably all different scents. I came back on here to see if anybody else had noticed something similar. One review says one of the Amish bars smelled like a knockoff Ivory soap bar. Yall, idk that it’s really worth the tin foil hat, but I would be willing to bet that they are melting down regular store-bought soap bars and adding bentonite clay and maybe one or two other things and then reselling. I even checked the ingredients between the two bars and they are ridiculously similar. The only major difference between the Dove and the Amish bars is the Amish bar lathers much better, does not seem to strip every bit of moisture and dry out my skin, and truly does do better on my face. I’m just curious if anybody else has noticed anything like this. Bottom line, however they go about making this soap, I do freaking like it and will end up buying it again. Idk what I’m gonna do if I end up with a dang rock or some metal or plastic in it like other reviews have showed….. probably cry. But now I want to know how the heck they are making it so I can try it on my own and save some dang money- ESPECIALLY if they are melting down cheaper bar soaps and adding a thing or two and reselling for twice the price. That’s my theory, take it or leave it. Still gonna buy more because I love it. : / Read more
timothy Eddolls—December 19, 2025
Great soap and you get double the amount that you do from leading others it's not really isn't the greatest but it does a good job with my skin Read more
dsk—June 14, 2025
I'm 64, so I've used pretty much everything in the shower, at one time or another. I came on Amazon looking for a honeysuckle soap that I bought from an Amish store in Ohio, when I ran across this soap. I saw reviews stating that you could wash your hair with this soap. I was skeptical, but I bought it. First of all, the bars are huge. I have medium sized women's hands and I could barely hang onto the soap. My husband is a big guy with huge hands and he committed on the large bar size. I had yet to find a soap with which I could wash my hair. My fine straight hair always looked greasy with any kind of soap. I tried the Amish soap it, hoping for the best. The first thing I noticed is that it lathers extremely well, but it rinses easily and thoroughly. The scent is very light. It leaves my hair smelling clean with just a delicate scent that works well for women and men. It doesn't leave any residue on the skin or in the hair. It doesn't dry the skin. My hair came out beautifully clean and shiny. For the first time, I can wait 3 days between hair washings. With my fine straight hair, I've always had to wash daily, otherwise it looks greasy. My husband has eczema on his head. I had him try this soap to wash his hair. For the first time, his head doesn't itch. He said his skin doesn't feel dry. We're still using the first bar for 2 months now, and it's still huge. It's a very long lasting soap; it doesn't take much to make a rich lather. Read more