Black Eyeliner No Budge Retractable Eye Liner Creamy Pigmented Waterproof Creates Bold Defined Lines Vegan Cruelty-Free Easy to

I got home from London and walked in on my roommate doing her makeup, which she is very good at. She’s raving about this amazing new eyeliner, how it’s exactly what she needed to get ready to go out, how it showed up at the perfect moment. I’m standing there like… what new eyeliner? Turns out she opened the wrong package. 😂 Apparently, it was a gift from the heavens. Once I realized it was mine, I took one look at how good it looked on her and said keep it. That tells you everything you need to know. So joint testing of the eyeliner.... It’s jet black, creamy, and glides on effortlessly. One pass and the pigment is there. No tugging. No patchiness. Once it sets, it does not move. Heat, long nights, getting ready in a rush. It stays put. Truly waterproof and smudge-proof to the point where you actually need real makeup remover to take it off. Looks really good on her! The retractable pencil makes it easy to control. You can do a thin, clean line or go bolder without fighting the formula. It feels lightweight on the eye and is never stiff or uncomfortable. I do not share eye makeup, and I definitely do not share toothbrushes. This one was review was done second hand by default, and I'm not mad about it.. She loves it. I love that she loves it. And at this price, I’d happily buy another. If you want a bold black eyeliner that performs way above its price point and actually lasts, this one delivers. Tested, tried, and officially claimed by someone who knows good eyeliner when she sees it. 💄✨ Read more

I picked this one up just out of curiosity, and it’s honestly impressed me more than most! The color goes on a deep, true black in just one pass, and the creamy texture makes it glide on smoothly without tugging at my lids, especially along the lash line. I really like that it’s buildable. On workdays, I keep it as a thin, clean line for a more natural look, but when I’m going out, I can layer it for something bolder without it getting patchy or uneven. Once it sets, it holds up well throughout the day. I wouldn’t say it truly lasts a full 24 hours on me, but it easily gets me through a long day and evening without smudging or giving me raccoon eyes. I’ve even worn it in the rain and had slightly watery eyes, and it stayed put. After about 8 hours, it does fade a bit on my waterline, but the liner on my lids remains intact. The retractable design is convenient, and the tip is thin enough for precision without being so fragile that it breaks easily. You do have to twist it up slowly and carefully, but that’s a small tradeoff. It removes with makeup remover, though you may need a little extra effort since it’s waterproof. Overall, this eyeliner has earned a permanent spot in my makeup rotation. It applies smoothly, stays put, looks richly pigmented, and performs on par with much more expensive brands. For the price, it’s a great value and a very reliable everyday black eyeliner!! Read more

Smooth application and easy to use. The eyeliner glides on without pulling and the black color shows up nicely. It lasts most of the day, though there’s slight fading after long hours. Good for everyday makeup Read more

I have gone through a ridiculous number of black eyeliners over the years, and most of them either smudge halfway through the day or disappear completely by dinner. I picked this one up hoping for better staying power, and it has definitely delivered more than most I have tried. The color goes on very black in a single pass, which makes my eyes look more defined right away. The creamy texture helps a lot because it glides on smoothly instead of tugging at my lid, especially along the lash line. I like that it is buildable. On workdays, I keep it to a thin, soft line that looks clean and natural. When I am getting ready for an evening out, I can layer it up and get a bolder look without it turning patchy. While I would not say it truly lasts a full 24 hours on me, it easily makes it through an evening without smearing or giving me raccoon eyes, even after a long day. The retractable design with the built-in sharpener also makes it easy to keep a precise tip. Bottom line, this eyeliner has earned a spot in my regular makeup rotation because it stays put, applies smoothly, and gives me control over how subtle or dramatic I want my look to be. Read more

This eyeliner is really nice to use. The pencil glides on silky smooth, making it easy to get precise lines, and the tip stays sharp thanks to the built-in sharpener on the back end. I like that it’s waterproof — after one application, it lasted days on my lash line. Even with makeup remover, some of it clings to the lash line, which shows how strong it is. The color payoff is rich and bold, so a little goes a long way. I found it easy to use for both thin precise lines and slightly smudged, smoky effects. Because it's a silky formula, it will smudge if layered too thick. Buyers should know that because it’s very long-lasting, you’ll need a good makeup remover for stubborn areas, especially near the lashes. Also, the waterproof formula might feel slightly resistant if you try to blend too much, but that’s normal for a long-wear liner. I feel like this is a high-quality eyeliner that’s perfect if you want precision, staying power, and a rich color that doesn’t fade easily. For anyone who struggles with smudging or watery eyes, this one holds up really well. Read more