Customer Review—November 22, 2025✓ Verified purchase
I am not a make up artist nor an influencer, I am just an older mom in her 50s that likes really simple no fuss makeup. I was looking for a good burgundy so I could wear a burgundy with maybe chocolate colored liner or shadow with it. So I came across this on a search in the dazzling burgundy shade. The color isn’t 100% burgundy. It’s kind of a burgundy and copper mix in my opinion. But you can apply it so easily and it is not dry at all. It does not pull or tug. I have very sensitive eyes, and this did not bother my eyes at all, and I took the picture by lining the top and bottom with no other makeup on (I don’t have my eyebrows done. I don’t have eyeshadow done.) This is just super plain to show you what it looks like. I think it looks great on my blue eyes. One thing to mention about when I was trying to do the swatch and then I tried to rub it off, it does have super teeny, tiny, micro sparkles in it. No, it is not chunky hard glitter, but it left behind this very subtle sparkle, like if you were using a special night out body oil if that makes sense. Now, once it was on my eyes and dried, it did not smudge. It did not budge until I literally washed it off with soap and water. I personally love it, and it will always be in my makeup bag. Read more
Franklin—January 19, 2026✓ Verified purchase
My go to eyeliner. Perfect for lining under lashes. Stays on lasts all day. Wouldn't call it smudge proof but if you wipe any excess away it stays put all day. Will continue to buy. Keep 1 at home and one in purse. Never want to be without. Easy to use. I've never had one break or melt in a hot car. Lasts for months. Affordably priced I've tried them all and always come back to this one. Read more
carlieb—December 7, 2025✓ Verified purchase
This is the better quality eyeliner. It lasts long and the color is vibrant. I'm running into trouble trying to find it in the stores so online I go. It's easy to apply and is smudge resistant. This has become my go-to for eyeliner. Read more
Brad&Hannah—December 2, 2025✓ Verified purchase
I love that this liner does not budge however, I have in the past had eyeliners that were even blacker in color and more buttery to apply. The matte texture is a little “harder” feeling when you apply it, so if you have skin that is fragile it might not be good for you. The great news is that it really does stay on all day. It doesn’t break when I apply it. It slides on the eye very dry that’s what gives it a very matte look. You do not have to sharpen this pencil because it is a twist up so no sharpening required. That makes it very easy to apply. But if you have sensitive and fragile skin it may be a little tougher, it might be better to try a liquid liner. Read more
Saby—October 12, 2025✓ Verified purchase
My go-to daily eyeliner has been the Sephora pencil in brown (with tiny sparkles). They discontinued it or something because I couldn’t find it anywhere. I’ve bought lots of brown eyeliners trying to find a replacement, but they’re either too light, too matte, or come off really easily. This eyeliner was amazing! Perfect deep rich brown color AND it has the tiny sparkles in it :) it’s also waterproof and smudge resistant, stayed on all day, and I’m sure I rubbed my eye by accident at least once, but it did not budge. So happy I found a (cheaper) Sephora replacement. New go-to! Read more
Customer—January 6, 2026✓ Verified purchase
My #1 makeup product. I hope they sell this forever, i have probably bought this 100x. Glides on, not thick or clumpy it’s smooth and the best color ever. Easy to put on and also great value for your money, it lasts a while even if used every single day. Read more
GiGI—July 28, 2025✓ Verified purchase
Doesn’t last on. Disappointed. Glides on easily though. Read more
Brie Burse—January 18, 2026✓ Verified purchase
I will buy this over and over. It is such a quality eyeliner and I use it every day. Read more