DeVa Darling—January 24, 2026✓ Verified purchase
I got this for my lower water line. It perks it up just right! When you reach a certain age, it's no longer wise to line with black etc. This does a great job brightening my lower water line! Great formula, stays were you put it, and last most of the day. Super value for the pencil and once you put it on, it doesn't smudge. Can recommend! Read more
Tess C—January 30, 2026✓ Verified purchase
This lash liner brightens my eyes, makes me look awake and fresh. Smudge resistant, sharp point and glides easily. Read more
smitty13—November 16, 2025✓ Verified purchase
This is the best eye pencil ever! I have the brown and black on my regular subscription and love to give it to friends as they usually thrilled with it too! Allows you to create a fine line like eyeliner, or you can smudge it for a more subtle look. It’s so thin that you can also use it on the water line and for me, without any irritation. Another amazing bonus is that it’s incredibly inexpensive. Out performs most of my $30 pencils! Read more
cleanfreak—February 3, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Ok doesn't really show up on waterline Read more
Jeannie Cap—February 28, 2025✓ Verified purchase
I love this waterline pen. Goes on smooth and it's the perfect color. Unfortunately, there's only a small piece inside, the size is a bluff. It also breaks easily. If I get a month out of use 3x/week... I'm lucky. Read more
Khadijah with a H—October 7, 2025✓ Verified purchase
I love this so much and I use it for my eyebrows! I love that it’s tiny and it gives me hair-like strokes. The color is just right, the liner lasts for the long time and it’s quite functional. Read more
Teresa K.—February 1, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Love the thinner point on this liner. It also doesn’t smudge like other brands. It’s my go to liner. Read more
Shannan—July 27, 2025✓ Verified purchase
I love Covergirl but I was really disappointed with this purchase. The pencil was very dried out. It pulled/dragged my skin and left a very poor color deposit. It was kind of like chalk tbh. Read more