Human # 4678843226)$$7&9—January 11, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Seems like this brand might be donezo but it was great while it lasted. I alternate between eyeko and Erin’s faces, my favorite liquid eyeliner of all time- they were also donezo, but apparently earth harbor bought the company and will keep the formula the same?! I sure hope so. Check it out if you were an eyeko fan. Read more
Customer—September 3, 2025✓ Verified purchase
I got a sample of this from ipsy and it was so good I had to buy a full size! This is the best eyeliner! Its not water proof, but I like it that way. One hiccup tho, it does dry easy, so sometimes I have to dip the tip in water to keep using it but thats a small thing to me lol Read more
Ashley Stacey—March 24, 2025✓ Verified purchase
This eyeliner is the truth. I have very oily lids and this has minimal transfer on its own, zero if you use a powder shadow as a base. Easy to apply, dries quickly, and lasts all day. Read more
R&Z—January 6, 2025✓ Verified purchase
I have been buying this eyeliner for a while and each eyeliner would last me MONTHS- keep in mind I usually wear winged liner daily, so that's a long time to still be going AND still be giving crisp wings. As other reviews stated, this is dry. It was ok out of the box, but still not as wet as my other liners have been, and the second time I used it it was already dried. I couldn't even finish my left wing and had to use my old liner...the one I bought literally back in March of last year. I shook it a ton. I left it upside down overnight. Nada. So either these are knock offs or Eyeko has changed the formula because sadly this is garbage, which is an utter shame because this was the perfect eyeliner. The holy grail of crisp, non smudging winged liners :( Read more
Myndie—September 19, 2025✓ Verified purchase
Wanted to like it more. Goes on evenly for a smooth line, but dries out easily. Read more
Fernanda—February 11, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Love it Read more
TheUFWD—December 16, 2025✓ Verified purchase
Love this stuff! I have super oily eyelids, to the point where I just cannot wear mascara at all, and most eyeliners usually start to give me raccoon eyes at some point. This is the best eyeliner I’ve used, has excellent hold with minimum to no racoonification. I’ve even fallen asleep in it and woken up either eyeliner still on and winged, which is a feat for someone like me (given the aforementioned oiliness). Use one of those makeup remover jellies to take it off without having to scrub and irritate your eyes. Read more
Trisha—July 27, 2025✓ Verified purchase
Edit: I got the replacement, it seemed a little more, ever so slightly black compared to the original one I received. That one was just soo sheer I had to go over it so many times. This one, it seemed like just 2-3 times to go over (but still too much for me). The first was neither waterproof nor smudgeproof. This second replacement I got seemed to stay on a little longer, but also wasn't waterproof and came right off super easily with a few droplets of water on my wet finger when I tried to rub my eye. I am going to try other eyeliners instead, from a brand called Macqueen which I have heard many things about. That one is a brush liner, compared to this Clio one which is a felt tip pen? Maybe that could be the reason? Not sure but I will be returning this and will only maybe consider the Clio brush liner in the future. I do absolutely love their mascara though. Unfortunately, this product was not it for me. Original 7/27/25: I wanted to buy some eyeliners on Prime Day to replace my go-to Stila eyeliner, just to see if there were any affordable dupes. What I look for is the pigment (I want a strong black color) and also a precision tip. I do want the lines to be black and smooth, not messy or sheer looking that I have to do it many times over the same line. The pigment is black still, but unfortunately compared to the Stila, I do have to use it many times to build up the color and get it to the same comparable level of black. My Stila also lasts for a very long time, so I think I will be returning this and just continue using my Stila and rebuying that. The only good thing about this is the precision tip. It is, indeed, comparable to the Stila and may even be even more finer. I have not used it long enough to see how long the eyeliner will last before it dries out, but overall it does not meet all my personal needs in an eyeliner, and it may be the right one for someone else. Read more