Melissa Lindborg—September 19, 2023✓ Verified purchase
I’ve been doing cat eye for 20 years now. So obs eyeliner is a big deal. I’ve tried many many many over the years and fell in love with this. I’ve been using it for years and it’s perfection. Doesn’t run in the corner of your eye, makes sharp lines. Then I recently ordered another so I could have a purse backup. The new one went on gross. No sharp lines at all, feathered on my eyelid when I put it on. Shiny (?) and weird. And it wasn’t old because the brush was plenty wet. So I went and got my old one from my purse, went on perfectly. I notice the packaging is different. I am praying to all of the Gods of Old that I just got a bad one, and not that the formula changed. Read more
Hidalgo—March 12, 2025✓ Verified purchase
Good product at a good price. Good value for the money. Easy to apply, good color, dries quickly. Read more
randsbens—April 9, 2025✓ Verified purchase
Love this eyeliner. But found it at competitor store for $1.25. Read more
abbeylynn—August 9, 2022✓ Verified purchase
This is favorite eyeliner for 7 years now because it is pigmented, stays all day, easy to use, fine brush tip which makes it so easy to create very thin lines, goes over glitter eyeshadow with a breeze and it super super affordable - there is nothing more I could ask for out of an eyeliner this why I have only have repurchased this one for this many years Read more
JMDH—November 16, 2024✓ Verified purchase
Does not chip or peel off?Twenty four hours stays on well, easy to remove with makeup remover Read more
Estephanie—August 9, 2025✓ Verified purchase
muy bueno la verdad nunca me defraudo a pesar de que es muy barato, antes ni lo conocia apenas acabe este comprare otro Read more
Roxanna—July 2, 2021✓ Verified purchase
You guys don’t understand how much I love this eye liner ,it can be a rainy day and your liner won’t drip on your face it will look brand new...and no mess cleaning it off doesn’t smudge ..will buy for the rest of my life lol Read more
Ashley Simmering—January 13, 2015✓ Verified purchase
It's an okay eyeliner. It has a brush aplicator and it is extreamly precise and goes on smooth. The only thing I don't like is that it needs to be layered on occasion, because it's not very pigmented. For the price it's a good eyeliner though Read more