Maybelline New York Tattoostudio Waterproof Long Wearing Eyeliner Pencil Makeup Deep Oynx 2 Count

I've tried probably every eye liner available, and this is my absolute FAVORITE! I hope they never discontinue it because nothing compares even close to this! Definitely lasts all day long (I won't sleep in makeup so I couldn't tell you if it lasts 36 hours, but from the minute I put it on until the minute I take it off, my eyes look the same). I wear contacts and have had problems with other eyeliner flaking onto my contact and not coming off. Even if a smudge of this gets onto my contact, solution gets it right off. Not sure why everyone has a problem sharpening this?? I'm on my 6th pencil and have had no issues, other than the "gel" clogs a sharpener more quickly than a regular pencil would (daily cleaning solves that problem, but I buy a new sharpener regularly as well). My favorite part of this eyeliner is that it does NOT smudge... I don't know if it's the shape of my eyes or what, but 99% of other eyeliners will leave smudges under my eyes to where I start to look like a raccoon come lunch time. This one doesn't budge at all unless I'm rubbing at my eyes! It is a Little more stubborn to remove, but come on, it lasts ALL DAY... you probably won't find an all-day liner that comes off in one second. A good makeup remover wipe will remove it with no frustration. I will continue to buy these as long as I can find them!!! Read more

After years of searching, trying many types of eyeliners and lots of $$$ (even considered having my liner tattooed on), I finally tried Maybelline Tattoo Eyeliner and it has great staying power! Been using this Tattoo Eyeliner for a couple of years and won’t use anything else. Being an older woman with hooded eyes, my eyeliner would smear or melt/transfer but this one stays put all day and has been on the next morning if I don’t take it off. (Shhh) Glides on easy, dark full lines and looks great. I’ve had no problems sharpening the pencil, use a good sharp sharpener & a steady turning. Read more

This is the only eye liner I use now! It’s stays on even after a shower if you don’t use remover. It doesn’t crumble off into your contacts. Great purchase highly recommended! Go swimming, cry, sweet. It wont come off until you want it off for at least 2 or 3 days depending on which hour wear you order. Only eye liner I use and have for years! I should be an ambassador for this company! This is all you need And mascara a a little lip gloss to leave and look gorgeous. Even if it’s the rufest day! I go through 2 sticks a month! That’s how dedicated I am to this company! Greta product! I highly recommend! Read more

Good product too bad I'm allergic to it. It spreads on smooth and the color is a nice bright black. Read more

I love this long wear eyeliner because it has amazing staying power. It does not chip or flake off in eyes and is great for people with contacts. It’s bold and dark and is a great value for your money. Read more

Smooth, go’s on gently, will smudge briefly with a small brush if you want blends nicely with shadow but it is staying put all day & looking fine the next morning too. Read more

These eyeliners will make a very dark line which I like BUT, you have to go over the line your making with them multiple times to achieve the desired effect. Once you have done that, the problem becomes that this eyeliner builds into a waxy substance that cakes off into small pieces that gets into your eyes! Tiny little grainy balls of caked up eyeliner that make you feel like you have sand in your eyes and you must constantly use your finger or knuckle to lightly pick the chunks of it off of your eyeballs. This eyeliner is in essence a plasticky wax that does not stay in place nearly as advertised but yet it is incredibly difficult to remove with makeup remover wipes and micellar water! I use both of those prior to face wash to ensure it is off before doing it all again! The only reason I am using this eyeliner is because I outline the "waterline" of my eyes as I have been doing as long as I can remember;) and this eyeliner can give a rich black on the "waterline" and despite the frustrating waxy pieces in my eyes, constant reapplying and enormous effort it takes to remove it; I have wasted alot of money on other eyeliners that haven't worked at all. Read more

Good quality, nice color. Stay well Read more