Bailey Horn—January 16, 2026
We bought a ninja creami for christmas and have been trying new ice cream recipes. We found this cake batter extract and have perfected our cake batter ice cream. It tastes exactly like Coldstone Creamerys cake batter ice cream (if you haven't had that, I'm sorry). Will be buying more!!! Read more
Autumn Rose—January 6, 2026
Absolutely loved it! Now that I’ve used it once, I don’t believe I can bake my cookies without it again. It’s amazing. Gives it that extra flavor I’m looking for. Taste just like cake batter! I highly recommend! Read more
Georgiannaj—December 25, 2025
I had seen on you2 about this flavor and that it gives your cakes a better taste couldn’t find it in the store and for the value. It’s a great price. I baked two cakes with this flavor and it does give your taste a very rich flavor Read more
Devine by Dezine—October 20, 2025
Wow! Love this stuff! I am a baker and bake cakes & cupcakes frequently. I recently decided to order this Cake Batter extract and give it a try. I made a yellow/butter cake and added a generous amount of this extract, along with a lesser amount of vanilla to the recipe and "Oh My Goodness!" it seriously took the flavor to the next level. I had several family members try the finished cake with the extract and everyone made the same comment, "The flavor was delicious!" This would be the perfect compliment to yellow cake, butter cake, birthday cake and Fun-Fetti cake. This is going to be a regular in my cake baking arsenal from now on. Take your baking to the next level and give it a try! Read more
Shawna s.—July 16, 2025
I recently tried McCormick’s Cake Batter Flavor Extract in my baking, and it’s quickly become a pantry staple. This 2 fl oz bottle offers a rich, authentic cake batter taste that enhances everything from cookies to frostings. Amazon ✅ What I Love Authentic Cake Batter Taste This extract delivers a genuine cake batter flavor without being overly sweet or artificial. It adds a delightful depth to baked goods and even ice cream. Versatile Usage Perfect for cookies, cakes, frostings, and even smoothies. A little goes a long way, making it a cost-effective choice for various recipes. High-Quality Brand As a long-time McCormick customer, I trust their products for consistent quality and flavor. ⚠️ A Few Considerations Strong Scent The aroma is potent when first opened, but it mellows out during baking. Amazon Slightly Yellow Tint The extract has a faint yellow hue, which is typical for cake batter flavors but worth noting for light-colored recipes. Read more
Carl—January 13, 2026
I love it. I baked my cake and I diluted as it was described and my cake was delicious😋😋😋 Read more
Nichelle V. Mclean—January 10, 2026
Great flavor Read more
Jaclyn—December 11, 2025
Love this product. I am a home baker that owns my own business. This is wonderful in our Birthday cake cookies! …. Just wish it didn’t have artificial dyes in it and price point was better. Overall, we keep buying because the taste is wonderful! Read more