GeeCee—November 21, 2025
What a great concept: one end for concealing and the other end for highlighting. Really useful and handy. The pencil "lead" itself is not so hard that it hurts your skin but not so soft that it easily breaks. I plan on getting more for stocking stuffers. Love it. Read more
E. S. Corbin—June 15, 2025
Easy to sharpen! I've had others in the past that I needed to take a utility knife to them to sharpen them because they wouldn't fit in a regular pencil sharpener, so the size is perfect. . This is a subtle, perfect eyebrow highlight shade. It goes on smoothly and is never chalky or cake-like. This will last quite a while too. The price was great. I'll be ordering more, absolutely! Read more
Patricia Johnson—January 6, 2026
Absolutely love this natural color. Blends in well and stays put for a reasonable amount of time. Read more
DC—January 6, 2026
Love this so much! I have never used this before but the pencil is very creamy and you and blend it out easily. The matte is great on its own without any other eye shadows. Definitely recommend! Read more
jannabel—July 1, 2022
I was so HAPPY to see NYX reintroduce a fine-point Wonder Pencil! I could finally stop getting into bidding wars on eBay and paying $35+ dollars for the last remaining light Wonder Pencils. But no... I don't want NYX to discontinue this, but *please* *please* take heed and make some changes. Pros: 1. the shade of the matte Light is still decent, 2. it easily sharpens to a fine point Cons: 1. Hardly deposits any pigment--old one was so creamy and pigment rich! With this one, I have to press really hard, over and over, to get anything to even deposit on my face. (I guess that's what some here and on NYX site mean by "waxy.") Even then, it's so faint--very, very light coverage. The old WP's pigment-richness and creaminess made it so quick and easy to use. "Quick" is important! This one takes forever to get about 1/4 of the coverage. (The bit that finally deposits looks fine, but it's never enough in many places). 2. Half is "shimmer." Why? I use matte concealer/contour pencil almost every day; I use shimmer maybe three-four times a year. So that half is mostly throw-away NYX: Please, please improve the texture and weak pigmentation. But please please *keep* the decent Light color (matte end) (could be slightly pinker for me, but it's not bad), and the wooden, sharpen-able, fine-point pencil. I'd also lose the shimmer, but I can handle throwing half away if the other half is a go-to. Please bring back the old, go-to Wonder Pencil!! Read more
Isadora—December 7, 2025
i use as a highlighter on my clients eyebrows, looks amazing. it is so creamy and works great Read more
BrandyLu—September 11, 2025
That's because it doesn't go lower. Not worth the gas to return it. First time I used it the pencils broke and it was down hill from there. Read more
BuckZoo2958—January 26, 2025
So I had a different brand of this concealer pencil that I bought years ago that is no longer around. I’ve searched for a replacement that had the same texture and color matching and hadn’t been in luck until now. I use this to shape my brows after filling them and the color matches perfectly. The texture is firm, but not dry and cakey. You can sharpen it so you always have a nice pointed tip and the highlighter side is good for those extra details. This is a pretty good sized pencil and should last me for a while. Read more