T. Nelson—March 29, 2025
These cookies are dangerously delicious. Like, hide-the-box-from-yourself delicious. They’ve quickly become my all-time favorite keto snack, and I honestly have to ration them or I’d inhale the whole pack in a day. They’re that good. Should probably put in a different container and label oatmeal or something. Portion Size: These things are quite large. One cookie easily feels like a full dessert—rich, satisfying, and enough to keep you from prowling the pantry. I usually cut one in half so I can enjoy a little treat twice a day. Half after lunch, half after dinner—it’s my version of adulting with dessert. Flavor: These cookies hit that sweet spot (literally) between indulgence and keto-conscious. They’re definitely on the sweeter side, and while you can tell they’re made with a sugar alternative, the flavor is still rich and satisfying. Not artificial or bitter—just sweet enough to scratch the itch without throwing your taste buds into confusion. The chocolate chips? Generously sized and melty when warmed. Yes, I sometimes microwave mine for 5 seconds and pretend I’m eating a fresh-out-of-the-oven bakery cookie. Moisture & Texture: Unlike so many keto cookies that taste like sawdust in disguise, these are soft, chewy, and moist—like homemade chocolate chip cookies. No dry, crumbly disappointment here. Just soft, pillowy goodness that makes your mouth happy. Protein & Keto-Friendliness: Each cookie packs 15 grams of protein, which means it’s not just a treat—it actually holds me over between meals. And with only 9 net carbs, it fits neatly into my keto lifestyle without guilt or glucose spikes. It’s like finding a unicorn in the snack aisle. Price: Yes, at nearly $2 a cookie (when buying the 12-pack), it’s more of a treat-yourself item than a bulk snack. But for the quality, size, and satisfaction factor, I think it’s totally worth it—especially when compared to the sad, overpriced keto snacks I’ve tried in the past. Dry and crumbly? Not today. Overall Ratings: Portion Size: 5/5 Flavor: 4.5/5 Moisture: 5/5 Texture: 5/5 If you’re looking for a high-protein, keto-friendly snack that actually feels like a dessert, this is it. Just don’t say I didn’t warn you—they’re almost too good. 😉 Read more
Customer—December 27, 2025
My hubby’s favorite and he’s sooo picky! A diabetics dream with a great taste and this box is the best value ever! They are expensive if you purchase the one at a time so this is a lot more cost effective and convenient. He says they’re purchase taste, not to hard either. Read more
Kelly Oldfield—November 30, 2025
I love most of the Quest cookies, but this flavor is a bit blan. and the cookies are dry. The service in ordering them was great Read more
Sam—August 23, 2025
These Quest Peanut Butter Protein Cookies are honestly one of my favorite guilt free snacks. They’re soft, chewy, and have a rich peanut butter flavor that actually tastes like a cookie not a “protein” product. With 15 grams of protein and only 1 gram of sugar, they’re perfect for curbing cravings while still supporting my fitness goals. I keep a few in my bag for when I’m on the go, and they’ve become my go to post workout treat or even a quick breakfast when I’m rushing. I also love that they’re high in fiber, so they keep me full longer without the sugar crash. If you’re looking for something that feels like a dessert but fits into a healthy lifestyle, these are definitely worth it. Read more
kim m glazier—January 3, 2026
I like these cookies because it has less sugar than other cookies. It’s good when you’re watching your sugar intake Read more
Theresa Miller—October 1, 2025
They taste ok but kind of a off taste . Kind of taste like a snicker doodle cookie but just a really odd texture . Read more
S.C.—June 27, 2023
🔹Chocolate chip cookies: In my opinion, the texture is more like "regular" soft cookies. There is a little taste but I'm not sure from what, could be from butter. I don't consume butter frequently so might not be used to the buttery taste. I prefer chewy cookies to soft or crunchy ones, but these cookies do satisfy my occasional cookie cravings. (For "regular" I'm trying to the ones with no protein, lots of sugar, lots of fat, and possibly lots of additives.) One thing to be aware: It has higher saturated fat compared to peanut butter cookies, since it contains more butter (second ingredient after the ingredients for protein blend). 🔸Peanut butter cookies: The texture ranges from chewy to hard, depending on the batch/package. The ones from previous box were chewy, but this time they're on the harder side. These cookies are more dense compared to chocolate chip cookies (thinner and break more easily). Butter is lower on the ingredient list, and these cookies are lower in sat fat. I would prefer the texture of these with chocolate chips since I like chocolate chips in cookies, but I like these cookies a lot. However, sometimes the box of both of these cookies are damaged when received, either the dotted lines were torn open, the tape seal on the box was opened, etc. I would review the seller differently, but I think these cookies are good!) I would try the other flavors, but they cost more. I've had the double chocolate cookies once but I don't remember, since I bought it at a local store and there were 4 in a box. Read more
Mandy Jenkins—September 29, 2025
Very good. Does not taste like normal healthy food or leave after taste. Read more