Traci—September 20, 2025✓ Verified purchase
This is very creamy. Like the brush. Advertised as good for anywhere on cool skin, I used it on eyes & lips. Tried contour challenge but not so good on that glides on easily and smoothly. Rich pigment. The length is lasting awhile. Good quality and reasonable price maybe just a little high for me. Use a stain liner more because of wear time Read more
Bill—November 8, 2025✓ Verified purchase
This is a great lip liner from always reliable Revlon. Colors are highly pigmented and definitely have staying power. A lighter touch in application with this liner ensures a smoother effect for lipstick application. Read more
LD—February 7, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Very creamy, great color, but does not last. This is not typical for ColorStay products. I would pass on this one. Read more
JM—October 3, 2025✓ Verified purchase
This is one of the best lip liners I’ve found so far. The color dallying is dark but it’s almost same color as my lips which has been impossible to find and the brush on the end is perfect. Going to get more colors. Read more
Angelica—October 8, 2025✓ Verified purchase
This is my current favorite liner for my lips I am on the constant hunt for the perfect darker nude/mauve liner. My favorite was discontinued and I want to find a replacement. I almost screamed in flight when I saw that this whole line is mostly focused on variations of mauves. I like to layer my liners if I have time. I put Dallying on first and then I darken it a little with Trace Off which I find too dark to use by itself. I love Trace Off on the eyes as well. I love drugstore gems because the price is always great! That said, it is a very creamy formula and I usually like my liners to be a little drier for a more precise line. I know the blurred line is popular and this is great for that. It is easy to use but you have to be a little careful when you sharpen because of how creamy it is. I have literally pushed the entire tip off and had to resharpen it. At least with sharpening liners, there is a lot of product and this one is long. It doesn't last all day but I like to reapply anyway. Overall, I recommend it. I want to get at least two more colors. Read more
Emily—September 14, 2025✓ Verified purchase
This liner in the shade Dynamic Doer is fabulous. Definitely a staple in my routine that I will continue to repurchase. I think it is a good value as I’ve used it every single day for several months now and the pencil still isn’t short and nubby. The product is smooth and glides on, blends easily with the blending brush, and once it sets it lasts a long time on me. I use it for both a lip liner and for my nose contour. I like a blush heavy look, so to put this pencil down first and blend as a base and set with a cooler tone contour powder works lovely for my fair skin tone. I really enjoy this product and would recommend it. Read more
M S—December 13, 2025✓ Verified purchase
This is such a great makeup product! It is so versatile just like the description. You can use it as an eyeliner, brow pencil ect! I am a very busy mom and my makeup is streamlined into quick and on the go. Just carry this pencil with a lip color/gloss, powder, and Bam.....ready and fresh! No stress no mess.....just makeup Zen. ✨️ Read more
j.dominguez—February 10, 2026✓ Verified purchase
I got this in Dynamic Doer and Less Traced. I like both of the colors for lip/cheek/eye makeup. It goes on smoothly and blends well. However, it lasts less than two hours with no drinking or eating. I'm wasting money and product every time I sharpen the pencil—nearly every time I use it, since it is so soft and the nib wears down quickly. Read more