Smudge-Proof Gel Eyeliner Set Long Wear Retractable Eyeliner with Ultra Thin Tip Angled Brush High Definition Vegan Makeup

This seriously lives up to the hype of being actually smudge-proof and my mind is blown. I rubbed and rubbed at the swatches I made of these and they didn't budge at all. I wet my finger and smudged really hard again on the swatches and they only very slightly faded but still didn't smudge. The texture of these is divine, they go on like a dream. You can definitely get very precise with the application on these because they are a very fine pen and with the colors they come in this opens the door to some very fun and creative makeup options that will stay put. Read more

I really wanted to love this eyeliner set. The formula itself is nice and it definitely stays on for a long time without smudging, which I appreciate. The retractable pencil and angled brush are also convenient and easy to use. Unfortunately, the shades weren’t quite dark enough for me. I prefer a deeper, more intense eyeliner look, and both colors applied lighter than I expected, even with a few passes. Overall, this is a good product if you’re looking for long wear and a softer definition, but it may not be ideal if you like a very dark, bold liner. Because of that, I’d give it about 4 stars. Read more

This duo eyeliner set is a fun way to add color without being intimidating. I really like that it includes two shades that both work well with brown eyes. The blue is a bright, noticeable blue with strong pigment, and the maroon is softer with a matte look that feels more everyday friendly. They look great worn alone or paired together. I did blue on top and the mauve on bottom and it looked good together. The colors also look great for my bright winter palette. Application is easy because the tip is thin and precise, and the formula is creamy so it glides on smoothly without tugging. It gives quick color payoff in one pass, and the little angled brush on the other end is genuinely useful for softening an edge, blending, or cleaning up a line. One downside for me is wear time. I tested the pigment on my hand and after about an hour it was already noticeably faded, so it did not feel as long lasting as I expected. It could be that I have very oily skin because I read it stayed well for others. If you want bold color that stays put all day, you may need primer or a setting step. Read more

This set of two Lithe smudge proof gel eyeliners are TRULY smudge proof. Included in the set are two colors: Galaxy and Blueprint. One is a medium, almost denim blue, and the other a raspberry color. Both very pretty!! The gel is more of a solid type liner that does glide on very very smoothly. On the other end you will find an angled brush to help smooth and define. Don’t wait too long.. once this liner sets it REALLY sets. As my first test, I drew small line of each color on my hand. Within minutes it set and would not come off, even when rubbing on it. I even tried to wash with water and a bit of soap. That did lighten the color, but it still stayed on. You will need to use make up remover in order to remove this liner, just FYI. BUT that is a good thing if you are looking for gel liner that is truly smudgeproof/semi permanent. Personally, I am very happy with these eyeliners. For the price, I feel like they are a great deal. Highly recommend!! Read more

I have mixed feelings about these eyeliner pens. Application was easy, the creamy formula glided on smoothly, but the tip broke twice while using it. I didn't apply a lot of pressure, so they shouldn't have broken. It's just a waste of product. The formula dries super quickly, which is great, unless you accidently get the color where you didn't mean to. Once it is on, it is on. I like that it is smudge-proof and waterproof, but I'd like to be able to take it off as well. The pen makes a very good line, even and full, and the colors are vibrant. I have very oily skin, so it was impressive that this doesn't smudge or run, making it great for my skin, but the formula seems kind of drying, so I don't know how it would perform on other types of skin. If you're looking for an eyeliner that makes good, smooth lines, dries quickly, and stays put, then these will work for you. The fact that they break easily and may dry too quickly to use the brush for blending or fanning is a concern, as is that it's very hard to remove Read more

Lithe high definition gel eye liner features a fine tipped eyeliner on one side and a black angled brush at the other end for blending. The duo set includes the contrasting shades blueprint and galaxy (a deep blue and mauve color). I have a little trouble with application. I have to go over the same place several times to get good definition and full color saturation. Also, even with a light touch, I have some trouble with the tips breaking off. These are very quick drying. Once fully dry, they are definitely smudge proof and waterproof. This product is well suited for all day wear. I had a very hard time removing it with just soap, water and a lot of friction. I needed to use a strong oil based make up remover to fully dissolve it. This has excellent staying power. I appreciate the vegan formula and that it doesn’t irritate my sensitive skin or eyes. Read more

i really like the two colors for these eyeliners. real quick, the reason why i gave this product four stars is because i wish it game as single products instead of two, as i really do prefer one color over the other. if i am forced to purchase both colors, and i dont plan on using it as often, it's going to be a waste. as much as i really like the two colors, and the fact that the liners stay on for the entire day practically, real talk, i see myself using one of the colors more than the other. i like that it comes with two different tip sizes for two different looks, and i also like that it does make me feel like i am using a premium product as there are many out there which makes me feel like i am getting what i paid for. Read more