stila Stay All Day Smudge Set Waterproof Gel Liner Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner Pencil for Tightlining Waterline Smoky Eye

Excellent eyeliner- meant to get black but kept this. Dries fast, and mostly stays put/no raccoon eyes. It smudges in the right way, the lines are sharp, and it’s easy to use. I’m getting another- even crying didn’t budge this stuff. Read more

I am so happy to have found this pencil in gilded green. I have amber eyes and this color is perfect for them. A long time ago I had an eyeliner pencil very similar to this but the brand stopped making it. I kind of gave up on ever finding it again but came across this by sheer luck. It’s a gorgeous vintage looking green with tiny sparkles. It looks super pretty on the bottom waterline. I’ve used lots of Stila eyeliner pencils and they’ve all been great. Love the brand and quality. Lasts all day on me, doesn’t smudge unless you intentionally smudge it for a smoky look and the colors have all been really nice. The pencil is kind of creamy but not too soft. Sharpens well and there’s not a lot of waste from having to sharpen it too frequently. The wood sharpens well too without splinting or having any sharp edges. They do not irritate my sensitive eyes or dry out my skin. I am an older makeup girlie (57) and these still look good on me even with the sparkles. So if you’re older I recommend you go for it. It’s super flattering and easy to use. Read more

The metallic olive color is beautiful and I did do a hand test and it really does not budge! It’s pricey but worth it Read more

The color of this eyeliner is bold and beautiful. The liner seems to last for the day, and can be blended easily if desired. Read more

Love this eye pencil, goes on easily and stays on through the day. Read more

I have spent tons of money on eyeliner that would last all day from the most expensive to the cheapest. One night while searching on Amazon I came across Stila stay all day so I thought what the heck I will give it a try. I ordered it put it up and forgot about it until today when I was putting my makeup on and found this in my dresser. I applied to my tight line and lower lash line. This eyeliner stayed true to its words. I applied it at 9 a.m. and it was still on at 10 p.m. when I took my shower even though it stayed on it was washed off easily with my face wash. I ordered mine in brown and I Love love love it!! As long as they stick to this formula and not change anything I will continue to order it and I already ordered me another one. It's a little expensive but worth every penny Read more

By the end of my work day (8 hr) the eyeliner was running and smudging! Did not like it at all. Color was black as stated but that was about it. Read more

This one gets three stars simply because it does not last all day. It does, however, last longer than most. Unsure if I will repurchase again. Read more