Sylvia—February 12, 2026✓ Verified purchase
This is the perfect pencil for me now that I have become allergic to most eyeliners. It provides more of a wide, soft line, but I feel that the sharp cat-eye line from liquid eyeliner was more appropriate when I was younger; now I don't want to look "made up." The hoda color goes with everything. The pencil definitely lasts all day above the eye (but not below). A hint for use: once I dialed the pencil out too far, and the tip broke off, wasting some of a fairly expensive product! It's quite soft, which is why it glides on so easily. Now I'm more careful. Read more
Customer—February 6, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Great eyeliner for older eyes! Goes on smooth and stays on. Will definitely buy it again. Read more
Juliette K Dillin—January 26, 2026✓ Verified purchase
A good glide-on eye liner, but some smudging on lower lid did occur after several hours of wear. Otherwise 5 Stars. Love the color and will probably buy again Read more
PPP—February 19, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Expensive but worth it. Goes on easily and stays put. Highly recommend. Read more
RJS—December 20, 2025✓ Verified purchase
I've loved this eye pencil for years. I have it in two colors. It glides on smoothly, no tugging. It always stays in place all day. I don't have any eye irritation. Removes easily with makeup remover. Overall, this is a great eye liner. It's rich in color, easy to use and performs well. Read more
Jazzseamom—January 25, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Soft and good color but it broke the first time I used it Read more
Judith Scott—December 3, 2025✓ Verified purchase
Goes on easily and easy to work with. Liked it best of all the eyeliners I've bought. However, part of the tip came off when I opened it - would have sent it back, but wanted to try it as enough was left. Something to watch if this is a consistent problem. Otherwise will order again and send back if it happens the next time. I ordered the black eyeliner after using the grey - the tip was fine as compared to the first order. I like the way this product glides on easily and is also easy to smudge if needed. Best I've used compared to many other products. Read more
sarah—November 8, 2025✓ Verified purchase
Yesterday was my first day of wearing this eye liner. I probably should wait a week until I complete this review. The liner went on easily. It really is a dark navy. I wish I could have tried a sample size, because I would like to have seen what the lighter shade of blue looked like. I would have picked that one, but I didn't want any sparkle in it. My eyes were a little itchy by the end of the day last evening. I am hoping I won't have that trouble today. The liner did stay on well as promised. Read more