abigail Haddock—February 13, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Best eyeliner and ive tried alot. Really lasts, doesn't budge but goes on so easily and sharp. Applicator doesn't fray, perfect size felt tip. Makes applying eyeliner just easy. Glide, softness is perfect. Color is opaque. Read more
kcey—February 13, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Stay on, color accurate, easy application. Good quality. Read more
Dina—January 10, 2026✓ Verified purchase
This eyeliner stays on all day. It’s easy to put on it leaves a sheen on your eyes. It glides beautifully The color is black black It’s not sticky, but it is difficult to get off if you don’t have the right eye make up remover I put it right above my eyelash line and have no irritability on my skin Read more
Lena—December 8, 2025✓ Verified purchase
Almost perfect, but does run if exposed to water. Sharp line when you first start using it, but then becomes a half dried out brush that doesn’t want to do what you want to. Read more
Adelaide—December 1, 2025✓ Verified purchase
This is such a solid eyeliner; both because of its affordability and its quality. I work double shifts pretty frequently, and this eyeliner has stayed put for 12-16 hours straight with no problems at all. The color is a deep black as shown in the pictures and applies smoothly (no going back over the same line countless times). I can't imagine ever going back to more expensive eyeliners now that I've discovered this one Read more
Oliver Ta—December 30, 2025✓ Verified purchase
This product is easy to apply and applies smoothly. It does not smear or distort the color throughout the day. I keep it in my bag and use it regularly when I’m on the go. For the quality and performance, it offers excellent value for the price and is a reliable everyday option. Read more
Shalimar Miller—January 27, 2026✓ Verified purchase
I’ve been a pretty longtime fan of wet n’ wild products, but this eyeliner just didn’t cut it for me. First of all, the tip almost seemed frayed. It had a few little wispies on it. The color was nice and the ink was pretty good. It went on easy enough. It didn’t seem that waterproof because when I went to fix it, I was able to just do it with a wet with water Q-tip. Make remover wasn’t necessary. I should preface this next part by saying I have extremely hooded eyes. Which is why I wear liquid eyeliner and not pencil. By the end of the night, any part where my eyelid folded back on itself, the eyeliner had pretty much rubbed away. And yes, I set it with setting powder. And it still rubbed away. I mean, the price was good, and I’m sure it would be fine for short wears in a place where nothing‘s gonna touch it, but it’s just not gonna work for me. I’ll keep it for costume makeup, but it won’t be my day-to-day favorite. Read more
Chloe Elizabeth—February 3, 2026✓ Verified purchase
By far the best eyeliner for the price. It goes on smoothly, and lasts a long time. The only eyeliners I’ve ever found to “top” are the Waterproof Liquid Nyx, which can be hard to work with due to its formula, and the Stila Waterproof eyeliner, which is 4x the price. This eyeliner has been a staple for years and will continue to be!! Read more