melissa—November 4, 2024✓ Verified purchase
I initially bought this because I'm a sucker for seasonal things and I needed eyeliner. Because it's a cheaper item, I had low expectations but this eyeliner is my new favorite so I ordered two more. It's very easy to apply and stays on all day. Read more
Sarah Wilkes—July 10, 2025✓ Verified purchase
This is the closest thing I’ve found to the NYX matte liquid eyeliner since they discontinued it. Read more
Tabitha West—December 15, 2024✓ Verified purchase
Love the design. Mascara applies well and is durable. Color is spot on. Great value for the price. Read more
Kristi Gillett—February 22, 2025✓ Verified purchase
Works beautifully Read more
Ginger Nash—December 19, 2024✓ Verified purchase
It goes on easily and lasts all day. Read more
mpd—November 3, 2024✓ Verified purchase
Great product. Easy to use and stayed put all night. Read more
Dan Yolodart—July 30, 2025
Great eyeliner. Works well, cute bottle. Read more
Felicia—December 26, 2024✓ Verified purchase
Great eyeliner she claims. She loves that it's Nightmare too. Read more