Maxine Kirsch—January 7, 2026✓ Verified purchase
I love this eyebrow pencil. It was exactly what I was looking for and makes a beautiful eyebrow every time. Thisproduct is fantastic and the price is terrific. I couldn’t be happier. I keep buying this pencil over and over again. Read more
Christopher Bennett—January 30, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Finally I found the perfect color match 625A! I love the retractable application- no need to sharpen and have shavings everywhere! Easy to handle, nice size, easy to grip. The other end is a good eyebrow brush. Thank you again, Wet &Wild! Read more
Sue G—February 5, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Excellent, inexpensive eyebrow pencil. A chiseled point allows for thick or thin application that lasts all day. I would like it more if it had longer definer in it. Read more
MVMcGinn—January 30, 2026✓ Verified purchase
I love this brow pencil- it works great and the color is perfect. Only complaint is I feel like its only half full- I go through more than a whole one a month so I dont think the actual brow pencil is as large as it looks on the outside. The price is right its just frustrating when companies play that way. Ill keep buying it because I love it but they lose a star for the misleading product size Read more
RJ—June 9, 2025✓ Verified purchase
I’ve tried several drugstore eyebrow pencils, and the wet n wild Ultimate Eyebrow Retractable Definer Pencil has definitely earned a permanent spot in my makeup bag. For the price, it seriously outperforms some higher-end brands. The angled tip makes it easy to fill in sparse areas with both precision and speed. You can create hair-like strokes or fill in more boldly depending on your look. The formula is smooth but not too waxy, and it doesn’t smear or fade throughout the day. I have oily skin, and it stays put even after a full day at work. Bonus points for the attached spoolie brush — it blends the product seamlessly for a natural finish. I use the Ash Brown shade and it’s a perfect neutral tone that doesn’t pull too red or too gray. Overall, this is a fantastic eyebrow pencil for anyone looking for a budget-friendly, reliable option. Highly recommend! Read more
Customer—January 22, 2026✓ Verified purchase
This has been a to for a while now. It’s smooth, easy to use and super pretty. It’s a great neutral brown without a red tint and lasts all day. Read more
tabbicat—December 20, 2025✓ Verified purchase
For the price point, I much prefer the NYX brow pencil for texture and ease of application. The Wet n Wild is stiff and unforgiving in comparison. I don’t like having to press so hard on the delicate skin around the eye. I ordered Ash Brown and the color is as pictured. Read more
Kate—January 22, 2026✓ Verified purchase
I thought I would try some thing a bit different and this is so neat and goes on so perfect. I have the ash color and it is the perfect match to my now light gray hair from blonde at my 77 years of age. Never to old to look and feel nice. Kate Read more