Eleanor Ruby—October 16, 2025✓ Verified purchase
It has very good dark pigmentation. It doesn't smear or run. It stays put. I can draw a very fine line or go over it a couple times for a thicker line. It lasts all day. I wear contact lenses and it doesn't irritate my eyes. I use it on my wetline and it works great. I'm 50 and it really is waterproof and easy to apply. The con about it is that the tube doesn't last long at all. I'm on my second tube. Read more
Emily G—February 11, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Almost left 4 stars because I COULD NOT get it off LOL but hey, isn’t that the point? So far the best eyeliner I’ve ever used. The felt tip isn’t stiff like most tips and it stays on literally until you power wash it off! Tip is super fine and saturated so it’s easy to apply, dries fast but not too fast and it’s so cheap. Love it Read more
Alex—December 7, 2025✓ Verified purchase
THIS IS ACTUALLY GOOD - better than drugstore pen options and so affordable. It stays put, contact safe, it works so well, it’s easy to apply and the pen tip never wears out like I used to get with maybelline, it’s thin enough to do a clean line but not so thin that I can’t do a solid wing. I’ll keep ordering this Read more
Cryssaa—January 15, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Good stuff. Goes on smooth. I wouldn’t say that it’s you is waterproof though. Read more
Ariel Clark—January 14, 2026✓ Verified purchase
I used to use a brand called Artistry that had excellent pigmentation. Unfortunately they have gone down hill in quality and since then, I have been hunting for a brand that I could rely on. Selestia blew me right out of the water! Thank you so much! It's very durable and water proof within reason (you really have to work to get it to smudge) I will be buying again when I run out! Read more
Sylvia—November 20, 2025✓ Verified purchase
Am still learning how to use liquid eyeliner. But honestly I only brought this item because it look neat. Cobra 🐍 snake head cap☺️ Read more
Lynifer Craft—February 16, 2026✓ Verified purchase
My fav eyeliner, though a lot of liquid comes out when you first use it. But it lasts all day as long as my eyes aren’t watering right after I put it on, if it dries before it starts (bad allergies) it will last all day. Read more
SD—August 3, 2025✓ Verified purchase
If you would like to look like cat-eyed-cleopatra, this is for you! I have this on auto order because it glides on easily, dries quickly and stays put for around six hours without smudging more than most at the same price point. Of course, it’s not invincible, so I wouldn’t recommend it for water sports or on a day you suspect may end with you getting broken up with or discover your beloved hamster escaped unless you want the cat eye to quickly become a raccoon eye, but overall I like this enough that I’ve ordered it over 5 times! It does dry up if you aren’t vigilant about ensuring the lid is on tight, but overall it’s one of my favorites, even while knowing I’ll likely want to touch it up every six hours or so. Read more
