awesome—June 17, 2025✓ Verified purchase
As an older woman, I struggled with liquid eyeliner smudging by noon—especially during busy workdays. MAC’s gel eyeliner is a game-changer! It stays put all day, looks sharp, and applies smoothly. This is now my only eyeliner, and I can’t recommend it enough! Read more
CAM—November 12, 2025✓ Verified purchase
Love it! For tight lining it works great. For mature eyes. Read more
Calebini—September 12, 2024✓ Verified purchase
I have found an eyeliner to replace a more expensive brand I used to buy. MAC Colour Excess lasts longer, and costs less! I've tried a couple different shades and like the ones I have tried. Product stays in place. Mostly I love that the retractable pencil lasts so much longer than the previous brand I used for years. Not looking back! Read more
Teresa Baskette—November 13, 2024✓ Verified purchase
This eyeliner is one of my favorites! The color is a rich brown that is not harsh. The texture is creamy making the application easy. I touch my eyes a lot during the day, but this eyeliner still holds up. I love that I don’t have to sharpen it to get a fine line. Read more
Julia—July 2, 2025✓ Verified purchase
Why did you pick this product vs others?: Glides on well, doesn’t stay on for too long. My friends always ask me where I got this liner from, I love it as I don’t wear heavy makeup Read more
Christa n—May 19, 2025✓ Verified purchase
I'm really pleased. My lashes are super oily and most liners(and masqueras) end up running down my face soon after application. It was a gamble I took that I'm so glad I did. Lasted almost 10-12hrs. Read more
Gracie b—August 19, 2024✓ Verified purchase
I use this liner every day and it goes on easily. To remove you must use an oil based cleanser. Read more
Pamela—September 3, 2024✓ Verified purchase
Just what I wanted. Color was perfect. I could smudge it where needed, Mt solid line stayed perfect for hours. Heads up though. Do not order if your package will be delivered in the heat. I wasn't thinking. It melted and it wouldn't turn up as I used it. But I will order again when it isn't so hot outside. Got here on time, delivery was perfect. Read more