paula—January 5, 2026✓ Verified purchase
I had been looking for a liner just like this and was very pleased to have found it on Amazon. You can apply it with an eyeliner brush and I like to take a sponge tip to smudge it giving it a more smokey eye look instead of a sharp line. It has great staying power, and will stay put till you take it off at night. I got the Blacktrack color bc I have light green eyes and when I smudge it, not only does it soften the look, but it makes my eyes pop! I'm 73 years old and it works very well for me Read more
Araceli Rodriguez vital—February 9, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Good Read more
Customer—December 22, 2025✓ Verified purchase
I have been using this clay eyeliner for years. It goes on so smooth and does not dry out, crack while trying to draw a smooth line. Read more
Wabbit—September 4, 2025✓ Verified purchase
Excellent eyeliner. Goes on smooth and stays in place all day. Read more
Mizbling06—February 4, 2025✓ Verified purchase
OMG this eyeliner is the holy grail of all eyeliners!! After tying I don't know how many eyeliners from branded to regular nothing ever stayed put all day long without smudging or smearing or even streaking like this one from Mac does. It was so good I even bought the brown one. Hope this never runs out of stock. Will buy it a thousand times over!!!!! Read more
Dana Krakowski—March 1, 2025✓ Verified purchase
Love MAC products Read more
Kailey—January 2, 2026✓ Verified purchase
I’m not sure what has happened with this eyeliner, because it used to be the best. Now by midday it is completely smudged and takes all of my other eye makeup with it. It’s also supposed to be black but goes on as an almost dark grey now. Read more
