sydschaffer79—June 30, 2021✓ Verified purchase
I’ve been using this eyeliner for a couple years now and it is the only one I use. The color is a deep black, it glides perfectly, easy to apply, stays on all day yet is no trouble to remove at the end of the day. As far as waterproof it is not but I’m not a fan of waterproof make up anyway. I struggle with beauty products because of my allergy to sls but this never gives me any irritation or problem. My favorite and will continue to buy for as long as it’s available. I don’t wear makeup much but it lasts so long I usually lose it before I even get to the point of it drying out and this is several months I’m talkin bout. Read more
Ossa25—February 23, 2018✓ Verified purchase
By far, the best eyeliner I have ever tried! The price is worth it for me, the shipping is not that expensive. I have tried eyeliners priced the same as this like The balm Schwing (worst eyeliner ever!) and the other brands from Loreal, Maybelline, Rimmel, etc. Yet they are not as good as this! I have used a good Japanese branded eyeliner too which was cheaper, but I forgot the name! So I bought this one instead. The felt tip pen of this one glides smoothly on the lids, does not fray like the other brands do, and is not very soft nor is it too hard. It doesnt smudge, is waterproof, colour stays on and does not fade throughout the hottest (and highest humidity of 90%!) summer on record here in New Zealand. But it is also easy to remove with just a face wash in the shower or my makeup remover wipes (Nivea brand). I couldn't find this anywhere else here in my location, so I had to buy from Amazon. Thanks! Read more
Customer—September 8, 2024✓ Verified purchase
I’ve been using this eyeliner for years after a Beauty Editor from an online beauty magazine swore by it on her Instagram. She wasn’t promoting it. A lot of her followers asked her in the comment section because she always has the best cat eye liner looks and thankfully she responded telling us about this liner. It applies smoothly and the sharp tip gives a crisp cat eye point. It’s jet black and doesn’t smudge. I pray this eyeliner is never discontinued. Read more
thistastesliketurtles—January 25, 2016✓ Verified purchase
I hate writing this review because I am terrified everyone is going to figure out what an awesome liquid eyeliner this is, and then it will be out of stock.. I do cateye liner just about every day and I've tried just about every eyeliner out there in liquid, gel, powder and pencil.. I get compliments all the time on how clean a line I have.. And it really stays all day unless I get allergy eyes and just the very corner of my cayeye runs off with the tears.. I never get raccoon eyes from this liner.. The tip is a brush tip which I tried to show in the photo.. The pen is the size of your average writing pen I would say.. It's the perfect girth and length for my hand to apply the liner steadily.. Sometimes I find that the brush gets a little crusty after a couple of weeks of use causing liner flow to slow.. That can easily be fixed by cleaning the tip base with a damp warm cloth.. I order this eyeliner on Amazon because of the free prime shipping and well, I just love Amazon:P Read more
DLS—December 26, 2024✓ Verified purchase
This eyeliner has a nice rich dense color , is long lasting and a fine tip. It can be applied easily. I took one star off because the tube does not seem to last as long as other liners I have used. But I have bought it multiple times because it is otherwise one of the best I have tried. Read more
Charlean Croxton—December 4, 2025✓ Verified purchase
I’m usually allergic to eyeliner. DHC is perfect for my allergies. Read more
Sumi—March 27, 2018✓ Verified purchase
The tips is great, makes it easy to apply (I have hooded eyes which is a challenge for me), it is a thin long brush that looks like a felt tip, flexible enough to bend when needed so it makes it easier to glide. The color is very nice black, I tried it for 3 times now, the first time it smudged badly but I thought it was because of the cream that was not completely dry yet. So the second time, I applied it right before I went to sleep (so my oily lids can do the test), I woke up all good, no allergy or puffy eyes, no smudges. But that same morning, I must have touched my eye because I saw that it smudged all over the back of my hand. This morning I did the same, applied it and it's all good, in the afternoon I pushed hair away from my face and then saw black smudged on parts of my hand, and it was the eyeliner. As much as I would like to say that it is because I toughed my face, I feel it shouldn't come off as easily, it't not as if I rubbed my eyes or that it rained on me, it was total normal things that I did. This makes me nervous to use it again as the smudges may end up on my clothes or things I use since it transfers so easily to anything once it is touched. Read more
IL—July 28, 2017✓ Verified purchase
I LOVE THIS! This is my second one and I am not changing to another product again. I used to be a die-hard fan of Stila Stay All Day Waterproof until they changed their formula. I am so glad I found this one. The tip is so smooth and precise, the tip was still in perfect shape when I ran out of ink. My last one lasted 7 months with almost everyday use. I have tried many different kind of liquid eyeliner and nothing can beat this yet. The waterproof quality is amazing! It survived two 1-hour bawling session without smearing off at all!! don't rub though, just pad dry ;) Try this!! 8) Read more