Customer—December 27, 2025
My lashes are loving this curler. Came with multiple inserts and they fit the width of the curler, no gap upcovered. I like the plastic clip that keeps the curler shut because debris does not get inside during storage or travels. Black finger pads allow for steady grip and do not move. Quality product. Read more
Palmetto Dan—December 26, 2025
As someone who regularly reviews beauty products and makeup tools, I'm genuinely impressed with the quality of this eyelash curler, especially at this price point. The e.l.f. Pro Eyelash Curler delivers salon-quality results without the premium price tag. The design is thoughtfully engineered with a strong, contoured frame that fits comfortably in hand and provides excellent control during use. The cushioned pad and precise curve work together to create beautifully curled lashes that stay lifted throughout the day. I appreciate that it comes with a replacement pad, which extends the life of the tool and maintains optimal performance. What sets this curler apart is how gentle yet effective it is. The silicone pad grips lashes without pulling or crimping, creating a natural-looking curl that opens up the eyes and enhances any makeup look. The strong spring mechanism provides consistent tension, and the handles are ergonomically designed to prevent hand fatigue during use. For anyone building their makeup collection or looking to upgrade from a basic curler, this is an exceptional choice. It performs as well as curlers costing three times as much, and the included replacement pad demonstrates e.l.f.'s commitment to quality and value. Highly recommend for both makeup beginners and enthusiasts! Read more
Andrea McCarrick—December 26, 2025
Great price and good quality. Curls my lashes perfectly. It’s easy to wash off any makeup that sticks to it. Read more
shopper—December 26, 2025
Worked well enough while it worked, maybe half a year. Pulled out more eyelashes than I hoped for, lol. Read more
Kendall B—December 28, 2025
Works great, the only problem I've had was that the rubber insert is constantly falling out in my bag and it's hard to find because it's so small Read more
Blueskies—October 16, 2023
Update after a year and a half: The wire spring that causes it to open broke mid-use. This is after a year and a half of use 5-6 days a week. The rest of it is so sturdy it could last for decades. Is this planned obsolescence? Really don't want to throw it away when otherwise it is fine, but with no spring, it is inconvenient. Per my first review; I replaced the rubber gasket with a separately purchased one, and it fits well. But the product should have come with the correct size in the first place. I am re-ordering this same curler, because at $5 it was a OK purchase. But the manufacturer should fix the flaws going forward. Original Review: I like this eyelash curler, but there's a design flaw. It's sturdy and well-made, BUT the rubber gasket doesn't fit. Either the gasket is too small or the slot is too big. It rotates in the slot and becomes partially dislodged so that the upper bar slips down beside it - sometimes breaking off eyelashes - and causing a gap in my eyelashes until they grow back! Not good. The gasket falls out constantly so it's always in danger of being lost, and needs to be replaced or re-positioned with each and every squeeze. I had bought this for a travel kit, but because it falls out every time, I switched it out with my home curler. I've been using this for months, so am probably past the return window, but it's so fiddly and exasperating that I finally had to post a real review. Hope the supplier/manufacturer sees this and offers a replacement. I want to love it because everything else about it is fine. Read more
K. Ford—December 24, 2025
I seem to go through a lot of eyelash curlers. This one seems to work well. Hope it lasts me a long time. I did pinch my cheek with it a couple of times when I first got it. User error I guess. I don’t have trouble with it anymore. Read more
Patriot—September 10, 2025
The e.l.f. Pro eyelash curler has a strong spring and a contoured shape that fits the eye comfortably. It curls lashes evenly without pulling or pinching, and the grip feels sturdy in hand. It works quickly, holds the curl well, and the included pad gives a smooth press without damaging lashes. The lightweight design makes it easy to use daily, and it performs as well as more expensive options. Great value for the price! Read more