Kaitlyn Lang-Ricci—January 27, 2026✓ Verified purchase
I’ve been wearing this eyeliner for almost a decade now. I love when people catch that it’s green because it’s not super obvious, but it’s different and light enough to complement various looks. It’s easy to do a wingtip with how these glide, and they don’t smudge easily. The moment I struggle with a wingtip I know it’s time to buy another, but they last a long time! Read more
Kindle Customer—January 28, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Favorite eyeliner to do wings with. It’s so easy to hold and the felt tip is thick so it’s easy to maneuver. It drys quickly so you don’t get that irritating line on the top of your eyelid. The only downside is after about a year or two it does dry out. Read more
Pam—October 27, 2025✓ Verified purchase
I struggle how to review this product with stars. I really like it and would buy it again. I'd do this knowing that it is not waterproof and will come off if I get water on my face or if I cry. The product claims to be infallible; it isn't. But, there's a lot to love. I purchased green. It is very pretty when applied. It isn't too bold but does give nice color and highlights the green in my eyes. I love the felt tip eyeliners. This one is a very good one. The amount of moisture is perfect. No clumps or drips. No dry strokes either. The price I bought this for was very reasonable, and as a L'oreal product, I know it is of good quality. Read more
Frankee—July 21, 2025✓ Verified purchase
This eyeliner has been around for a while, but I only tried it now because I was in the mood for blue. I usually use liquid liners but struggle with smudging, even with waterproof ones. Japanese brands have been the only kind that really work for me, though even they have started smudging occasionally. I hesitated to try this one because it has a felt tip instead of a brush tip, but the blue color drew me in. It was a pleasant surprise. The felt tip is soft and easy to use. The dark blue is subtle yet strong enough to enhance the eyes like black. The liner lasted over twelve hours with no smudging, which is a big win for me. My only issue is the formula felt a bit dry during application, and I hope it does not dry out quickly like another brand I tried. Read more
C.R.—February 13, 2026✓ Verified purchase
My go -to eyeliner for years. Great colors and priced right. Read more
Nekoatl—July 26, 2025✓ Verified purchase
First use it was delightful, didn't smudge or smear and was easy to apply. But after only a few weeks of use the color gets weaker or fainter upon application. However, it's not expensive so maybe you'll need to replenish more frequently. Read more
Lynette—February 4, 2026✓ Verified purchase
While this stays on better than others you can't expect any eyeliner to stay if you rub your eyes. This can make a thin line or wide. Read more
Martha—August 6, 2025✓ Verified purchase
Truly Smudge-Proof and Waterproof! I accidentally took an 7 hr nap mid day and woke up with my eyeliner still on, still perfect, still “fleeked”. It’s one of the best liquid eyeliners I’ve used. It’s super easy to put on, you don’t have to force the liquid out. And it’s very black, not like a dull black. Which I love. Like I said this eyeliner lasts a verrrry long time! If it can withstand my 7hr nap, especially with me being a hard sleeper and tossing/turning, it’s worth it! Read more