LOr al Paris Voluminous Smoldering Eyeliner Black 0 087 oz Packaging May Vary

This eye pencil--made by L'Oreal--is of excellent quality, especially for a "drugstore" eye pencil as opposed to fancier, more expensive brands. The color is a deep black, as promised, and it is easy to apply, even if you're not used to lining your eyes. I don't consider myself a pro at using eye pencil on the top eyelid at all--I can't use the liquid eyeliners, for instance, and never had luck even with pencil-lining the top eyelid. But I wanted to try to line my upper eyelid with black liner, decided to try this L'Oreal pencil, and was not disappointed. It is very soft--it doesn't hurt your eyelids to apply it, and it doesn't pull. It's sharpened so that you can make a fine line if you want. (And it comes with a sharpener.) If you want to go thicker, you just apply a bit more. It is not smudge-proof (don't know if it's waterproof) but it looks beautiful on, and will last for a half a day--at which point you may have to add a bit more. If you buy it, you won't be sorry. It makes you eyes look great! Read more

I LOVE this eyeliner! I never, literally ever wear eyeliner. When I came across this jumbo pencil I ad to give it a go. I am so glad I did. The pencil comes with a sharpener in the packaging which is nice. The pencil glides right on. I had no issues drawing my eyeliner on, making a wing, or removing this product after use. It’s a very bold black color. The thickness allows you to make the line how thick or thin you wish. I did not have issues with smudging. I will continue to buy this product when needed. I am now on the hunt for more colors of this same product! Great for all makeup lovers alike! Good for beginners and experts. So easy to use! Read more

L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Smoldering Liner, 645 Black, 0.09 Ounce ~ This is a good pencil. It goes on smooth and lasts for hours. I got an extra to keep with me for touch ups. The pencil stays sharp for quite some time so the pencil lasts longer. The bonus pencil sharpener works great as well, making this an excellent price. Its not Lancomb but it's a good pencil. It works great for a smoky eye too. Read more

I was not expecting to love this as much as I do. It goes on super smooth, and does not hurt my sensitive eyelids at all. I had minimal flaking/smudging, and the color is rich and dark. It is wider than your typical eye pencil, so if you lose the sharpener, you'll need a new one. Read more

This is a great eyeliner so sorry I can no longer find it in stores. Easy to use and the “smoldering “ effect is great! Comes with large opening sharpener! Read more

Love the liner! Wish it didn't somehow eventually get under my eyes. But it is a great product and goes on nicely. Read more

Very pleased with this eyeliner and have used it for years. Easy application, long lasting, looks great. Read more

This chunky eyeliner is one of the best ever it goes on very smoothly and doesn't irritate the eyes love it!!! And you also get a bonus which is the eyeliner sharpener great!!! You can't go wrong with this one. Awesome!!! Read more