Andrea Schweizer—February 11, 2023✓ Verified purchase
This particular eyeliner pencil actually looks like liquid liner, but it is the easiest thing to apply. You barely touch it to your eye, and it glides on like butter. No pulling on skin, nothing. I do it with one hand. You can keep everything super straight easily. I always do it over eyeshadow as well. It stays on great ALL DAY! The little rubber thing on the end helps to blend/smudge eyeliner on the bottom lid if you want. Once I discovered this pencil, no other pencil even comes close to comparing, even the really high priced and high end ones! And I have tried A TON!!! This is by far my favorite eyeliner EVER!!! :) Highly recommended!!!! Read more
SoCalBuy—November 5, 2025✓ Verified purchase
I’ve been using this eyeliner for over 20 years and it’s still the best! It goes on smooth, stays put, and gives that rich, intense color I love. I honestly can’t live without it — nothing else compares. Read more
Archangel—May 23, 2025✓ Verified purchase
This is by far the best eyeliner ever I’m a man wearing it and get compliments all the time Read more
Keisu—October 17, 2013✓ Verified purchase
Hi! I really like this, I just got it and it's very intense, goes on very easily, is perhaps a little hard to take off but that just might be my method, but overall a very good product! At first, I was freaking out because I didn't think it sharpened, but guess what: it DOES! All you have to do is sharpen it, don't think about how it all looks plastic and like you shouldn't be putting a sharp edge to it, ignore that. It actually is wood and sharpens just like any other pencil eyeliner if you use any normal (eyeliner) sharpener. Don't throw it away just yet! EDIT (October 8th, 2014) I also have to warn that it can be really messy on your hands, as it has creamy leftovers. You'll have to scrub to get it off. Tip: refrain from wearing white shirts before you put on your makeup! Read more
Annette Allen—January 3, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Glides on smooth Read more
LastBabyBoomer—November 4, 2025✓ Verified purchase
I found this eyeliner tricky to apply and even trickier to remove. I ended up with a mess. Maybe with more practice I would like it but I don’t have the patience for this product. Read more
sherri—November 9, 2021✓ Verified purchase
I love this eyeliner! It goes on soooo smooth & easy. You can make it very dark or light for day wear.People always ask me how I got my liquid eyeliner on so straight, perfect and inside my eye & doesn’t it burn putting it there?So my answers to that usually are:it’s easy, thank you, but it’s sooo not perfect!As for burning my eye • hell noooo because I use the best eye pencil ever,and I’ve tried top of the line ones,$1.pencils,in between ones, and nothing comes close.I thought Loreal was full of themselves when they say” liquid eye pencil”on the package, but it’s so true. Ladies if you want a great eyeliner this is definitely it. Well worth every penny.The one con is just lately…when you go to sharpen it the pencil gets very jagged & if you aren’t careful you can gouge your eye out.So ladies,after sharpening, check the point & the surrounding wood.Luv you girls & be careful…Sherri with 1eye….hahaha Read more
Lisa Mahan—October 14, 2024✓ Verified purchase
This is my favorite eyeliner I’ve ever used. I’ve been using it for years and am glad I can still find it. It goes on smooth and stays well throughout the day. It comes off easily with remover. Read more