BrilaβJuly 16, 2025β Verified purchase
Vastly superior eyeliner! Turns out, I have 3 other eyeliners in similar dark shimmery brown shade. from descriptions other user made online, I expected a slightly lighter more caramel brown color. Butβ¦ I kept it bc I like Mac products. I played around with the liner and saw that, while the color is similar, everything else about it is better: -The way it glides on my lids. (Not too soft. Not too hard.) - The finish and beautiful look of it is hard to describe. It is super natural, but also it very much stands out and flatters my eyes and skin tone -While it has some sparkle to it: (itβs a shimmer satin, but not a glitter finish) itβs not too much sparkle that it looks bad on my aging 40βs skin - It stays on and stays put. Lasts all day/night. Read more
STELLA MEOLAβFebruary 5, 2026β Verified purchase
Not smudge proof but glides in very nicely. Makes for a great Smokey eye. Read more
Lupe DresslerβAugust 26, 2025β Verified purchase
Great color, defines the eyes without being too dark Read more
JRβJanuary 26, 2026β Verified purchase
The best! Read more
anthony c.βOctober 28, 2024β Verified purchase
a great pencil to line inside of the eye! no irritation Read more
luvbnamomiβFebruary 13, 2026β Verified purchase
I've been using this color for years. I was worried to buy it off of Amazon, but it didn't disappoint. Read more
Donna McGillivrayβJanuary 27, 2026β Verified purchase
My go to eyeliner! Iβve ordered my second pencil now. Glides smoothly and blends well. Read more
Maurice GriffinβJanuary 31, 2026β Verified purchase
As advertised Read more