Elizabeth Martinez—December 3, 2025
I bought the color Lets bounce. I like the smoothness and color payoff. I find you don’t have to press at all. The liner last long too. As far as the color, I find it a little too dark for me so I will try other colors. I am medium olive skin tone and I found this a little too dark for me. I usually wear pink brown lip colors and I don’t like the liner too much darker than the lip color. Read more
Faith Wratto—December 11, 2025
Great on the lips and glides easily. Definitely worth your money and last very long. Read more
Kathryn—January 5, 2026
Wow. I love this lip liner. When I buy lipliners I value, and try to find products with, good color match for my skin/lips, price, ease of application, and longevity. And my goodness I think this one hits all of the marks!! I would say this is longer lasting, but I personally like to reapply my lip liner every couple hours, however for the price of this lip liner?? Excellent value. And I am so pleased with the shade Upstate, which matches my lip shade amazingly. I will be purchasing again, and would 100% recommend. Read more
Angelica—March 6, 2025
These creamy lip liners are wonderful. So far, I have three-Big Lift, Line Leader and On It. Big Lift is a pinky brown with a hint of mauve, Line Leader seems to be a fan favorite as a dupe for Pillow Talk but to me it is just a pink liner that I wish was just a shade darker, and On It is a true cool toned brown (side note-I apparently don't look good in cool toned brown). The pictures Maybelline provided are not accurate in my opinion and reviews I have read say that the darker ones are much darker than anticipated so keep that in mind. The liner itself is so creamy that if you press too hard, it will fall apart but I love that once it sets, it sets. This is a great one for blending and creating an ombre effect. Lipliners that require sharpening are my favorite and everyone keeps complaining about sharpening plastic but I haven't had an issue at all. I do wish that I could have a nice sharp point but you can't apply enough pressure for that nice skinny line I like to start with because of how creamy it is. There is no smell or taste that I can tell. And one thing I love about sharpening ones is that they last longer. These aren't the tallest lip liners but they are long enough to last a long time. They are so worth the $8 I paid for each one and I plan on getting more as I want darker shades and I have all the lightest ones. I apply Big Lift with Petal Lifter gloss and it is my favorite current combo but when I touch up I use On It to just add a little darker line. I think these are by far the best liners I have used from the drugstore-they have hyaluronic acid so your lips are moisturized, they have staying power, they are affordable and they have a beautiful shade range. Honestly, I could go on and on, I love them that much. I just wish they were a little less creamy. Give it a try. You won't regret it. Read more
Usman akbar—December 12, 2025
I absolutely love this lip liner! The creamy formula infused with hyaluronic acid and jojoba oil glides on so smoothly and feels really comfortable on the lips — no tugging or dryness like some other pencils. The pigment is rich and builds easily for outlining or filling in the lips, and it pairs beautifully with my favorite glosses or lipsticks. The liners stay put throughout the day without smudging or feathering, and they still feel hydrating (which is huge for me).  The precision tip makes it easy to shape my lips exactly how I want, and the range of modern shades means there’s something for every look. It’s a great drugstore find that performs way better than the price suggests. I’ll definitely be repurchasing Read more
Bernalgirl—December 26, 2025
Very easy to apply, this lip pencil has great texture and stays put — it doesn’t get stuck in the fine lines above my upper lip. The color is true to the photos and doesn’t change on application — no orange! Great value for the price. Read more
Alice—November 19, 2025
Didn't expect this lip liner to become one of my all time favorites at all, but it did! It has great pigment, you can build it up if you want, and it definitely is long lasting. I love the shade "Line Leader", very close to the pillowtalk. But compared to pillowtalk this forumula is not as dry and glides on easier. Will definitely repurchase! Also this shade is fair skin approved! The shade doesn't pull too orange or grey or purple on me. Read more
Marilyn B Washburn—October 25, 2025
This is kind of difficult to review and I wasn't sure how many stars to give! So here's the good: I like the color, it glides on like a gel, and seems to have staying power! The bad: The sharpened tip broke off immediately upon opening because its TOO soft...basically gummy. The end of the pencil twists as if it's retractable...but that feature doesn't function at all. I tried to sharpen the end but the product is so soft that it just kind of collapses. I think it'd work better with a lip liner brush. Anyway, that's the good and bad I guess. Read more