binky—November 5, 2024✓ Verified purchase
Super creamy formula, I do wish it was a tad bit pigmented though. I know that there are darker black eyeliners. However, I love it and it works great. No smudge after sweating or prolonged wear. Definitely a great buy and you get many of the pencils <3 ! Now I just need a sharpener lol. Read more
Siresa—January 12, 2026✓ Verified purchase
These eye liners are great for the amount and price is right also Read more
Toya Jackson—February 16, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Great Value, Read more
Anna—September 1, 2024✓ Verified purchase
Especially if you run out fast like me! downside and why the 3 star review is that its extremely light almost like grey and not a darker black liner... wouldn't purchase again Read more
K. E. M.r........rss—June 19, 2025✓ Verified purchase
For the price I didn't expect much but these eyeliner pencil work out great for my eyes. The pencil stays on and doesn't smudge. Read more
Kindle Customer—August 16, 2025✓ Verified purchase
It's really nice doesn't last long though it's good for a couple hours Read more
Crystal M—February 26, 2023✓ Verified purchase
This product is not smudge proof, and comes off just from wear, you don't even need to touch it and by the end of the day is mostly gone and very light grey. Read more
Krishna Amoi—February 1, 2026✓ Verified purchase
No it didn't work for me Read more