CLIO Superproof Pen Liquid Eyeliner Ultra Precision Sponge Tip One Stroke High Pigment Color Waterproof Smudge Proof Long

Love this one! The color is a deep, true black, it dries quickly, and it’s really easy to use. It might be because I’m already used to this type of eyeliner, but I absolutely love it. I usually order beauty products from Yesstyle or other online stores, and this one honestly compares really well. It glides on smoothly without skipping. I just hope this one lasts for long time! Read more

Really good, long lasting, dark eye liner. I have a few liquid eyeliners I rotate through, and Clio Killer Black eyeliner is one of my favorites. It doesn't smudge and it is easy to draw on. Read more

My go-to and always reliable waterproof black eyeliner. I prefer the brush tip, very precise. Stays on all day! Read more

I have probably tried almost every liquid eyeliner out there. KVD, Stila, Marc Jacobs, Tarte, Anastasia, Lancôme, Nyx, and the list goes on and on. I’m always on the search for a smudge proof, waterproof, long lasting eyeliner. I have hooded eyes with oily skin and it’s just a combination for eyeliners to not last. I also laugh a lot which means I tear up at the corner of my eyes causing those other eyeliners to smudge off or bleed. Nothing is worse than eyeliners that smudge and make you look like a raccoon at the end of the day. I can tell you what is wrong with every single one of those other eyeliners I have used but you don’t have all day. I tried using all those with primers, setting sprays/powders, etc and nothing works or lasts. I have come to terms with the fact that nothing will last all day on my skin and I will have to settle for “good enough”. This eyeliner seems to last for the most part and just fades slightly by the end of the day. It doesn’t flake off or rub off, but just fades so that the pigment is not as strong and could probably use a reapplication. I prefer that to flaking or smudging and I have accepted that this is really the best I can get with my oily skin/hooded eyes combo. The felt tip, as some have mentioned, is really hard (not flexible) so that when you are applying, it can actually hurt your eyes if you’re not careful. (But I still prefer this to a brush tip.) I only need to go over the line a couple times in order to get the shade/intensity of black that I like. After that I am good for the rest of the day. For the price point and lasting longer than all those other eyeliners that I have tried out there, I’d say I would buy this one again. Read more

It does what it claims. Thin line, no smudging. Decent product that works Read more

I'm absolutely in love with their mascara and have not been able to find a good eyeliner so I wanted to give this a try. The applicator is amazing, but the material itself is not great. I have to go over the same lines 2-3 times to get it all black and filled in. The wing just wears away in like 3-4 hours. Read more

My favorite eye liner. Smudged free and long lasting. Easy to apply as well. The formula is great. Very affordable too. Read more

This is the only eye liner that has worked with my oily eyelids. Easy to apply and stays well in place through the day. Dries quickly as well! Read more