Sweet Demise—July 30, 2025
I was really surprised by the performance of this sharpener. Perhaps because it is very reasonably priced. But I found it to work way better than its higher priced competitors that I have used in the past. It indeed works/sharpens like a CHARM! Highly recommend!!! If there was one thing I could change about it, it would be the cap at the back. I am not sure why it is designed to even come off. It is not snug so it keeps popping off. Or perhaps it just happens to be loose on the sharpener that I received. But that doesn’t affect its functionality in any way and if I had to get a replacement, I’d still replace it with the same exact sharpener. Works great! Read more
Customer—October 24, 2025
Okay, I didn’t expect to be this excited about a pencil sharpener, but the e.l.f. Dual-Pencil Sharpener totally surprised me! 😍 It works perfectly for both my regular eyeliners and the chunky lip pencils — no breaking, no weird uneven tips. It’s super easy to empty and clean (which I love because I’m messy), and it’s small enough to throw right in my makeup bag. The cover keeps everything clean and neat, which is such a win. If you use eye or lip pencils at all, trust me — you need this in your makeup kit. It’s affordable, convenient, and just does exactly what it’s supposed to. Love it! 💄✨ Read more
Amazon User—December 2, 2025
I honestly don't know entirely how to review this but Amazon has been asking me to so I will. It's a pencil sharpener. It sharpens my eyeliner pencil nicely. It has 2 sides, one is much larger, not really sure what that side is for? I mean I do have some white eye liner crayons but IMO it's not ideal for that, I wouldn't try it. It's an essential for the eyeliner pencil though. I went everywhere and could not find one of these, not in school supplies, the beauty isle, nothing. The one I did see in a store was twice as expensive as this too. This one also has a case to hold the pencil shavings in which is nice because no body wants to stand over the garbage can every time they sharpen their eyeliner pencils, especially because most of us probably realize we need to sharpen it when we're already running late getting ready. It's just an overall good choice, best I could find anyways, but like I said, it's just a pencil sharpener, not sure what people expect here from a review, yall should know what a pencil sharpener is. Read more
Sophie A.—December 11, 2025
Does its job, easy to use, nothing out of the ordinary. Basic sharpener, nice to have in makeup case, and easy to store. Read more
Anonymous—January 2, 2026
This worked on both my wooden and soft plastic lip liners. Created a very pointy tip without taking too much product off, and doesn't cost an arm and a leg. I would recommend! Read more
Shannon—January 4, 2026
I’ve tried a lot of sharpeners, but I keep coming back to e.l.f. This is the best one I’ve used. Many sharpeners dig chunks out of your pencils resulting in the liner falling out or breaking off. Not this sharpener! It works well and leaves my pencils with a smooth, fine point. This sharpener is small and travels well. Read more
valerie jones—November 30, 2025
I am 79 years old. I grew up in the 60's and it was shave off your eyebrows. Well FYI they don't fully grow back. So with that pencil has been my life. I have gone through many sharpeners in 50 years. I did modeling and normal living. My rule wake up get ready. Last always never leave my home. I have my mascara and eyebrows.🤣😂🤣😂. This sharpener is primo, super sharp cutting, only takes 1 or 2 full turns. 👍💝 Read more
Christy—December 6, 2025
Great price. Works great. The top kinda slides off sometimes but still works great Read more