I really enjoy using the e.l.f. eyeliner pencil because it goes on smoothly and glides easily without tugging on my eyelids. The color is vivid and stays consistent throughout the entire day, which I really appreciate. Occasionally, the eyeliner will smudge slightly at the corner of my eye, but it doesn’t happen often and hasn’t been a major issue for me. I also love that it comes with a sharpener—it works well and sharpens the pencil without wasting a lot of product, which is a big plus. Another thing I like is how easy it is to remove at the end of the day with makeup remover wipes. Overall, it’s a great everyday eyeliner, especially for the price, and I would definitely repurchase it. Read more
Smooth, easy to apply, stays in place but also easy to smoke it out of desired. Long-lasting, comfortable to apply, I've used it for a couple months now and not once has the tip broken on me, very good quality. Pigmented. The little sharpener that it comes with is also very good quality and it never splinters my pencils, I've used it with all my pencil liners for that fact. I have it applied on pics provided on waterline, to fill in eyebrows, and as my lip liner. Used in the stitch-scar too. Despite my heavy use of it, it hasn't gotten smaller. 🤣 Read more
For a couple of years I was buying the more expensive eye/brow liners and now that I've used them up I am back to these cheaper ones. Honestly I can't tell the difference. These are just as good, if not better than some I've paid five times as much for. Because they are a little softer, they go on smoother. And because I'm a nurse and I'm careful not to touch my face, especially during flu season, they don't smudge and stay put just fine. Can't beat the price. Read more
I like the overall length of the pencil. It's a true black that's not too soft that it crumbles and not too hard that it pull the eyelid. The sharpener works well as the cap. Hoping I don't accidentally cut myself while searching for it in my makeup bag. Overall a nice eyeliner. Not waterproof nor smudge proof. Read more
Super convenient and easy for Travel. It glides on really smooth so it’s easy to apply. Sharper is the tip cover which is nice. Read more
Nostalgic, have a lighter near by. Return to the 1980’s. If you know you know. Read more
Great eyeliner,cost effective Read more
I love this pencil!! Best one I've found in a long time!!! Creamy, glides on and lasts beautifully all day! The biggest plus is the built in sharpener! Shear genius! Sharpens perfectly, and evenly, no sharp woody points to deal with!! Ordering 2 more colors today! Read more
