PrincessRabbit—January 9, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Love this little liner. Goes on and stays on all day. It's soft and easy to apply in between the lash line. Brown is a beautiful natural shade which gives a little definition to the eye. Great price! These ELF products are amazingly quick brilliant. Read more
Tracy—January 29, 2026✓ Verified purchase
My new favorite eyeliner. Very few make pencil eyeliners that aren't self sharpening. I like to sharpen my own for a finer tip. Recently discovered this one and I love it. Very inexpensive, doesn't pull on my lid, goes on smoothly, and lasts. Also, highly pigmented. I am telling you...this is unusual! My new go to. Please don't stop making this eyeliner!!! Read more
Kanna—January 2, 2026✓ Verified purchase
It goes on smoothly and gives a nice, soft smoky look that’s easy to blend. The color is rich and stays put most of the day. I’m giving it four stars because the price is close enough to other eyeliners that have wowed me, so the difference of a dollar might make me get the other brand. But the color was what I was specifically looking for so it does have that on other brands. Would recommend. Read more
Suz E Q—January 17, 2026✓ Verified purchase
I bought this to replace a wooden pencil, that has been discontinued, from another, very expensive brand. Lucky me! I like this one much better than the one I’d used for years, and can buy about 5 of them for what one of the previous ones cost. It goes on very smoothly and stays all day. Doesn’t smear. The plum color is beautiful…very dark. Looks great with green eyes. Will definitely buy again! Read more
Janice C.—January 10, 2026✓ Verified purchase
This goes on smoothly. I am older and some liners are difficult to put on my delicate, less than smooth, eye area. It stays on well and is smoothable and smudgable. Really a nice eyeliner. It will buy it again when it runs out. Read more
carolyn—January 26, 2026✓ Verified purchase
I think it’s a great eyeliner it goes on very well and lasts all day. I ordered another one because o don’t want to run out. Good product Read more
Alexandria Christensen—December 17, 2025✓ Verified purchase
I was excited to purchase this eyeliner because I had heard good things about it. The size of the eyeliner is just right, and the color was exactly as I expected. It glides on smoothly and dries quickly. However, I noticed that it lacks longevity. Within 30 minutes of applying it, the eyeliner began to wear off, and by two hours, it felt as if I had never applied any at all. Read more
Gina Renee' Peregory-Sam—January 29, 2026✓ Verified purchase
My Favorite eyeliner, so silky smooth & the colors are so vibrant. Lasts all day without smudging. Read more