Alchemy—January 9, 2026✓ Verified purchase
I was a HUGE fan of the Maybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Pen, but had issues with it flaking and getting into my eyes and darkening my under eye (though it was a long time favorite). I had tried NYX professional liner, wet and wild, and the e.l.f. liquid liners, but I absolutely adore Heroine Make's for my eyes. I have seen minimal smudging from my top lash to my bottom lash line (usually I just need a swipe from my q-tip on my under eye after 3-4 hours and it looks as good as when I first applied it). My eyes are fairly watery and sensitive, but it's also lasted me the whole day (10 hours). The nib was a bit dry, so adding a drop of water helped being out more of the product. I absolutely love both the black and dark brown color and I've been told it looks very natural on me. The nib is also perfect for applying between my lash line and waterline for that tight line look. Read more
Alexis—January 4, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Amazing eyeliner and definitely my favorite. It super sharp line and very dark color. It does stay on all day for me as well. Read more
RRReview—January 12, 2026
Eyeliner application wasn’t easy for me until I found this Heroine Make by KISSME Liquid Eyeliner Pen with Ultra-Fine 0.1mm Tip. It’s the ultra fine tip that makes application easy for me. I’m able to stay along the lid line without a thick blur line. Once on, this eyeliner is smudge proof and waterproof. And it lasts all day and into the evening. That’s great longevity for eyeliner. I ordered the brown color for a change from the usual black color, and I really like it. This is a high quality, richly colored, eyeliner pen that is well worth the $16 price. A great value for a makeup item of this quality! Read more
M******—January 14, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Started using this 4 years ago and have never gone back. This is the only product that can keep my lashes LIFTED all day! After discovering that Asian lashes are often particularly stubborn and downturned, I decided to give Asian-made mascara a try… and WOW! The waterproof version is very waterproof, easy to use, easy to build, and long-lasting. Comparable to in-store prices in the U.S. if not way cheaper. Read more
N. Lan—February 13, 2026✓ Verified purchase
The best liquid eyeliner that I have ever used. Easy to apply even for beginners. It doesn’t smudge and stay all day. Super waterproof and still easy to remove Read more
Customer—December 6, 2025✓ Verified purchase
My go to eyeliner. I have horrible allergies, this eyeliner isn’t irritating and does not rub off. I came across this in Japan and ran out of my stockpile. Read more
john—October 16, 2025✓ Verified purchase
My eyelashes darkened really well, and the amount of thickness was perfect. The smudge resistance was great- it was really, REALLY smudge-resistant. it dries quickly, which is great for long trips or for fashion. Glide is perfect. The durabillity is great, too. It is a great product, and I recommend that you buy this to improve your eyelashes. Read more
LT—October 12, 2025✓ Verified purchase
I have been using these liners for years and absolutely love them. Unfortunately one of the liners I got was clearly a used and returned item. The liners typically last for months, but the one dried up after just a few days. Read more