Christine Hainen—January 21, 2026✓ Verified purchase
I'm no make up guru, but these work well for me. I've been using these for a couple of months now. I can't stand my eye liner looking like sisters, not twins and this takes the guess work out before looking like a racoon trying to make them even. The wing on them is a little thick, so if you prefer a sharp wing, I'd suggest another product. The set comes with 2 pens, both with 2 sides - 1 is just a regular liquid eye liner. Side 2 is marked L and R for each eye and is a stamp for the wing. I have no issues with these smudging or coming off during the day, even after accidentally rubbing my eye, but it does come off well with some micellar water. Read more
A. Schweizer—February 10, 2026✓ Verified purchase
This is the easiest eyeliner you can buy! Seriously. I always had problems drawing it on but no more! I’m pushing 50, have hooded eyes and my eyes water in the cold. No smudging. Just buy it. Read more
NathyGHomeReviews—November 13, 2025✓ Verified purchase
My 14 year old daughter is using this for her performances (theater) make up. She likes that is super easy to apply, easy to remove if needed but will stay on otherwise. The look is amazing and the color is intense. I wish it was not as expensive and can’t speak as to how long it lasts, but we hope it doesn’t dry out any time soon. Read more
Eliza A. Syta—January 9, 2026✓ Verified purchase
I don't leave reviews often, but after using this product I needed others to know, especially if they were on the fence about trying a stamp like this. I was hesitant to try because I'm almost 44, I have a few wrinkles, its hard to get my eyeliner on straight with a regular pen, and have even tried stencils in the past with disastrous results, BUT these stamps are amazing! It takes a few tries to get them perfect, but it has saved me so much time and they look great! If at first they don't line up, just qtip it away and try again. Please give these questions a try! Read more
Bethany Rock—January 10, 2026✓ Verified purchase
The eyeliner was super easy to use, long lasting, however the one stamp dried out after ONE use. Used it on my self and then went to use it on my daughter and it stopped working. Nothing has fixed it. Super disappointing as now that makes both stamps useless but the eyeliner side is good Read more
Lindsay S.—June 4, 2025✓ Verified purchase
This is hands down the best liquid eyeliner I've ever used and I'm so glad I found this on Amazon again because recently I ordered what I THOUGHT was this eyeliner - it was also a stamp eyeliner and when I received it, the color kept skipping, the tip was barely wet and I was SO upset because I thought I had ordered THIS eyeliner and was ready to leave a scathing review about the quality going so downhill. As I logged onto Amazon today to leave said review, is when I noticed that I didn't order this one! I've now added this eyeliner to my shopping list so that I never mistakenly order the wrong one again! What I love about this eyeliner is obviously based on my personal preferences but hopefully can help someone decide to give it a shot: * The longevity of it - and not just that it STAYS ON all day (it does!), but also the eyeliner pen itself lasts SO long, I can go almost a year before having to replace it, and I wear eyeliner almost every day! It does come with 2 pens, so that's definitely helpful. * The MATTE look of it. I can't STAND any type of shine on my liquid liners. I have no idea why I loathe it so much, but if I ever buy a new eyeliner and there's any type of shine on my eyelid I clean it off and throw away the eyeliner immediately. This is the perfect matte and I feel like the formulation of the liquid dries so smooth and flawless looking on my lids. * The COLOR of it. I can't explain it, but it's NOT a super HARSH black - however I wouldn't call it gray, or even charcoal. The pigment is great, but as someone with light blue eyes, I can appreciate a black that isn't TOO black, as a really dark black can tend to look stark against light eyes. The black shade of this eyeliner just works wonderfully with my eyes. *The PRICE for two pens and just how long they last. I know I mentioned how long these eyeliners last up above, but I just ordered these for $8.99 (on sale). Personally, I don't own much high-end makeup even though I do wear makeup everyday. My makeup bag is majority drugstore products. But even with drugstore products, you'll never find a drugstore liner that gives such great payoff for less than $5 a pen. I've tried Wet & Wild, Essie, you name it - none of it stands up against these eyeliner pens for the price you pay! Even at full price, these are a great buy and I wouldn't hesitate to buy if they were listed at full price. I was just lucky to come upon these at the right time. So glad I found my beloved years-long-loved eyeliner again. One last FYI: Do NOT get the eyeliner stamp pens in the gold and black striped box... they tricked me and they SUCK! :) Read more
Heather Amoss—February 6, 2026✓ Verified purchase
So easy to use as a stamped wing or as a base for a dramatic wing. Stays put and does not smear smudge or transfer Read more
maegan—January 28, 2026✓ Verified purchase
These are amazing! Smooth application! All day wear! Super easy to use! I have very sensitive skin and have had no irritations with use! Non smudge perfect product! Would highly recommend for fast easy use! Read more