YJones—February 7, 2025✓ Verified purchase
I am so impressed with this liner, I have to leave a review! I have been wearing liquid eye liner for about 40 yrs. (I started young!) Ive tried a lot of different liners. I could never get the pencil liners to look neat and not smuge. I have large blue eyes. I feel in love with liquid liners. I love the precision and ease of a smooth brush applicator and the liquid to get into creases and create a smooth line. In recent years it is difficult to find a liquid liner with a brush or softer applicator tip. I have been searching for one. They have been replaced with the rigid felt tip 'pens'. For some people this might work, but as I have developed a few extra lines around my eyelids I found that the stiff felt tip applicators were very messy to work with and get a smooth line. We'll I'm not sure exactly what this tip is made of, lol I do believe it is a brush, but I instantly feel in love with it!. I've been looking for a while to find this. I noticed it was very easy to guide and glide across the eye lid with ease leaving behind a very smooth line. I gently brush/tap the applicator against the rim of the cap to make sure I have a sufficient amount on the tip, without having too much. I use the water proof because my eyes tend to get watery from allergies, and I often use eye drops for dry eyes. What a mess that creates if you don't use waterproof liner! I wear foundation and eye shadow as well, and start with a moisturizer in the morning to hydrate my dry skin. I was amazed that this liner did not smudge or bleed when exposed to the moisturizer in my foundation! I put on foundation first. This liner stays put! After applying to each eye, give it a just a few seconds to dry and set in place, sometimes I give it a gentle swish of fan with a little card I keep near by. In less than a minute it's ready for the day! I really hope they don't change this formula or applicator tip any time soon. It seems like when we find something that works, it often gets changed. The price of this liner is amazing, you dont have to sacrifice other things when you are in a budget to use it, and it does seem to last longer than many others I have tried. I hope this works for you as well as it does for me! If you aren't use to using a liquid liner, practice and be patient until you get the hang of it. It really gives your makeup a professional look, as you can go as light as you like with it or as bold as you wish to! Read more
Victoria Bryda—February 6, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Nice black finish. Doesn’t smudge. I don’t use the adapter piece. But the product itself glides on smoothly and a super fine line. If u make a mistake comes right off with a Qtip. Read more
J. Every—July 13, 2025✓ Verified purchase
Very nice eyeliner. I saw an ad of someone using the cap to do a "perfect wing", so I ran straight to Amazon to buy. The cap is useless. BUT I do like the eyeliner. Just don't know how this cap is supposed to help with a perfect wing. Read more
Romero—November 23, 2025✓ Verified purchase
I swear by this eyeliner but it does have some issues. Don’t leave in a hot car, it will leak. The little hairs on the tip will start getting damaged and will leave streaks outside of the line you’re creating, so i remove these hairs with like an eyebrow razor when that happens. And if you’re doing like powder glitter eyeshadow and then put the eyeliner over it, the hairs start getting dirty and when it dries out the pencil gets ruined. BUT it’s VERY BLACK, long lasting, helps you do that perfect eyeliner, etc. So I keep buying it despite these issues because I know I will look good the entire hang out! It does last but it might get damaged before you run out of ink if you do a lot of powdery products in your eyes often. A way to make it last longer is doing eyeliner first, then eyeshadow, and then retouching any areas that might have gotten stained with the eyeshadow. I haven’t found any affordable black eyeliner as good as this one so I’d recommend you getting it lol Read more
KB—November 23, 2025✓ Verified purchase
I’m bad at eyeliner wings but trying to improve. After several attempts with this eyeliner and guide that weren’t great, I realize this isn’t error proof but just makes the initial outline easier. I still struggle with connecting it perfectly to upper eyelid. I’m interested to try it with other pens. I would say the pen itself is also not the best I’ve used, as it doesn’t come off very smoothly and can look bad after multiple attempts to draw a line in the right place. Color is good though and it dries quickly and is easy to clean with standard micellor water since it doesn’t seem water proof. Not my go to liquid eyeliner but will probably still use it. The cat eye guide was definitely the major selling point for me, though. Read more
Riese—January 27, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Excellent thin line! Applies smoothly. Stays on all day without getting crumbly. I haven’t used the cat eye tracer but I didn’t buy it for that. Read more
Minoes—January 31, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Stays on very well, easy to use Read more
L.L.—February 13, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Awesome liquid pen eyeliner.as long as you know how to use it use your hands,this application is vy good.vy good product.ive learned a Ling time ago don't need to pay 28$ for an eyeliner felt tip pen. Read more