Maria @ The NovaVi Edit—February 9, 2026✓ Verified purchase
The media could not be loaded. I wanted to share that the Maybelline tattoo long wear 24 hour eyeshadow stix with the Matt finish is definitely high-quality eye color that goes on creamy and dries with a beautiful flawless powdery finish. The applicator is similar to an eyeliner cream pencil which allows for that great precision and easy application. The color is vibrant and lasts a long time. It does not smudge and it is easy to apply for multiple layers. I have purchased eyeshadow pencils that were way more expensive and nowhere near captured the quality of this Maybelline eyeshadow pencil. This pencil is great for beginners that are doing eyeshadow makeup and perhaps are having a hard time working with powder. I highly recommend this Maybelline eyeshadow pencil for a beautiful flawless finish! Read more
Wildflower—January 19, 2026✓ Verified purchase
It goes on easily and stays ALL day. “I am cozy #110 is a nice neutral tan, not too dark not too light. Absolutely no complaints Read more
Aubrey Anderson—January 15, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Mixed feelings. Easy to apply in the waterline. I inly use it for that reason. I find it doesn’t blend whatsoever on my skin. It’s stays put all day! The color is definitely opaque black. I’m happy overall with the purchase. Read more
A.E. and Z.A.—February 5, 2026✓ Verified purchase
This is super long-lasting, and the color stays matte even on my oily skin. Also it's brilliantly buildable, so I can create whatever shade of black I want, from a jet-black cateye look, to a more natural, subtle look. It's perfect for day-to-evening: I can create soft, smokey eyes in the morning, and then just add more to get a dramatic, midnight-black look for evening. Even when I wore it to bed, I woke up with it still looking perfect! Read more
Sara—February 2, 2026✓ Verified purchase
I absolutely love it. Stays all day even without a primer, no setting spray. Color is absolutely gorgeous on eyes. The only down fall is it's too sticky. Just dab a bit of clear powder. 👌 Read more
DeVa Darling—February 14, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Nothing wrong with the eyeshadow stick. It applies well and stays were you put it. No smudging! However, it turned yellow-brown on me so I had to return it. If you're warm toned, this would work well for you. Not so for us cool toned ladies. Read more
A. Thomason—February 4, 2026✓ Verified purchase
I love the eyeshadow brighteners from Thrive Cosmetics, especially the shade Muna. I decided to try this (I Am Cheeky) to see if I could use it as a replacement. It’s a beautiful color and I absolutely love it! It’s extremely close to the muna shade, I’m switching. It lasts on your eyelids and blends well. Read more
Aly—February 11, 2026✓ Verified purchase
I like this color tattoo much more than products 6x this price. Smooth, applies lightly or more depending on your preference. I use this for a creamy shadow and sometimes as a soft or defined eyeliner. Does not break, flake, skip or deposit color unevenly. Also no unpleasant reaction to use Read more