Nitish—December 16, 2025✓ Verified purchase
This Gel Eyeliner delivers intense, richly pigmented black color that stays put throughout the day. Its smooth gel formula glides on easily and builds effortlessly for dramatic or subtle looks, while the 24-hour wear and waterproof finish keep it from smudging or fading. Perfect for long days or nights out, this eyeliner provides bold definition with reliable staying power. Read more
Samrat Roy—July 1, 2024✓ Verified purchase
The Maybelline New York Makeup Eyestudio Lasting Drama Gel Eye Liner in Blackest Black is a popular choice among gel eyeliners for its rich pigmentation and long-lasting formula. Here's a detailed review: Key Features: Intense Pigmentation: The "Blackest Black" shade offers a deep, rich color that stands out and defines the eyes effectively. Suitable for creating dramatic, bold eye looks. Gel Formula: The gel consistency allows for smooth and precise application. Can be used to create a variety of looks, from sharp, defined lines to smoky, smudged styles. Waterproof and Long-Lasting: The formula is waterproof, ensuring it stays put throughout the day without smudging or fading. Advertised to last up to 24 hours, making it ideal for long days or special occasions. Brush Included: Comes with an applicator brush that helps in achieving precise lines and detailed looks. The brush is designed for easy control, even for those who may not be experienced with gel liners. Pros: Longevity: Many users appreciate the long-lasting formula that doesn't require frequent touch-ups. Pigmentation: The intense black color is a standout feature, providing a bold and defined look. Waterproof: Effectively resists water, sweat, and humidity, making it suitable for all-day wear. Versatility: Can be used to create a range of looks, from subtle to dramatic, thanks to its smooth application and blendability. Affordable: Offers high-end results at a drugstore price, making it accessible and budget-friendly. Read more
Tuan—January 6, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Such a beautiful eyeliner 🥲 such a great price for it too which makes it even better. Gives the most amazing pigmented color and she’s waterproof af! If you’re looking for a nice gel eyeliner, this is the one Read more
Anika—July 19, 2024✓ Verified purchase
For years and years before I stumbled upon this product, I have been using pencil liners to line my waterline and eyeliner - but I haven't been as satisfied with the results I got from those. This gel liner came with a brush which allowed for a very precise application. However, I will say I didn't really like the brush itself too much as it can be a little prickly to the feel and it hurts to put on my eyelid. But I just use another tiny brush and it works out for me. It stays all day long, I went into a pool with this, put it through intense sweaty workout and this didn't bleed or budge at all! I love the rich black color as well, it definitely is much blacker than any eye pencil can give you, and I can especially tell on the waterlines. The brush can get pretty stiff though if not cleaned out properly and it can get a bit messy, so just make sure you clean the brush regularly. It feels really weightless on the face and it's great quality! Definitely give this a try!! Read more
Spencer—September 4, 2024✓ Verified purchase
The Maybelline Eyestudio Lasting Drama Gel Eye Liner in Blackest Black has quickly become my go-to eyeliner! The color is incredibly intense—a true, deep black that makes my eyes pop. The gel formula is smooth and glides effortlessly onto the skin, making it easy to create sharp, precise lines, whether I’m doing a simple look or a dramatic winged liner. One of the standout features is its staying power. This eyeliner lasts all day without smudging or fading, even in humid conditions. It dries down quickly but gives you enough time to perfect your line before setting, which I really appreciate. The included brush works surprisingly well for precise application, too! I’m thoroughly impressed with the quality for the price! Read more
Central Florida Big Dog Mom—November 9, 2025✓ Verified purchase
This used to be my absolute go-to, daily eyeliner. I prefer a cat eye, and this used to have the smooth application and longevity I needed. Something has changed in the formula over the last year or so, and it no longer spreads smoothly. It also migrates a lot more than it ever did previously, even when paired with primer or setting spray. I continued to by this product thinking that maybe I received old product, but even when I buy it from different retailers - the results continue to disappoint. I have switched to Anastasia Beverly Hills waterproof crème color (which you can buy on Amazon). It costs a little more, but it’s also larger. ABH has a smooth application like this product used to have, doesn’t migrate, and dries quickly. Read more