This isn't my first time purchasing this specific gel liner. First time I got it was years back, but in black. I love this gel liner because it actually LASTS on my waterline. Any other eye pencil - it would disappear from my waterline within 10 min or less. This? It lasts for several hours, if not the whole day. It has great staying power. I love the texture, it glides on seamlessly like butter. I was happy to see they had this brown. I am very pale and black can sometimes look extremly harsh on me...so I got the brown this time and it looks great; it's a nice, cool, dark brown that doesn't overpower my eyes. Application is easy. I feel a little goes a long way because it's very pigmented - it lasts forever. The smudging tool at the other end is helpful to blend out the liner. I should really get a few more of these so I can stay stocked up! Read more
Great product Eyeliner quality Ease of application Stay on Value for money Color quality Longevity Smudge resistance Waterproof Read more
This is my go-to. I have a lot of tears, and this has never failed. The black is a nice, deep black, and goes on smooth. Definitely not like a liquid, but the smoothest pencil I have tried. Easy to twist for more and long lasting. Read more
Love the deep black shade and the ease of applying is top notch but even after smudging as I always do, it doesn't stay where you put it, I was hoping it would not bleed under my eyes but it does, I use very small amount to just line the corners. It's a nice easy glide and does not tug. Read more
Love this eyeliner. I use to wear black. But decided to go lighter. Started using thisMaybelline in brown. Waterproof. Goes on smooth. Doesn’t smudge, or flake. Comes off with a couple of wipes with a makeup cleanser or wipe. I have been using Maybelline waterproof eyeliner for many, many years. Love this stuff. You can lighten or darken line. Smudge with sponge on end with cover. Price is great. Who needs expensive makeup from Sephora!! Read more
I love this brand. I have oily skin and my makeup likes to run off. This stays mostly intact with very little running through a 12 hour shift. It is pretty waterproof and requires makeup remover to take off. The color quality is excellent with the black showing up very defined and dark. Read more
This color was not charcoal. It was a light brown. It has no lasting power. I wear it on my waterline, and it’s gone within 30 minutes. Read more
This is my only eye liner that I use!! It goes on nice and smooth and dark! I can make it as thick or as thin as I want. I like that is retractable so no need for a sharpener. It's a great price and worth it! It lasts all day! Read more
