CustomerβDecember 1, 2025
I love this. It lasts all day (and I usually have oily eyelids by the end of the day). It stays put and it looks good with green eyes. It's a very subtle color too. I would buy this eyeliner before I bought an expensive brand. Read more
Dawn StegnerβDecember 27, 2025
This was honestly the best eyeliner I've used. It doesn't smudge and its waterproof. It works well and looks very nice Read more
MerrywhitneyβDecember 13, 2025
Love this eyeliner. Waterproof, smudge proof, lasts all night. With out the raccoon eyes at the end of the night. The tip makes it easy to apply also, and make detailed lines. Need make up remover to remove it fully. Glides on easily and a good value for your money cause there is a good amount in there. Read more
Samantha TweedyβDecember 22, 2025
Color is cute if you can soften it enough to look burgundy, otherwise it looks dark brown/black. This is kind of hard to blend or adjust after you apply even while itβs wet. Read more
Personal Vegan ChefβJanuary 12, 2026
LOVE the fine like achievable with this product. I order on repeat. Read more
sheshopsalotβJanuary 14, 2026
It's kind of watery, and leaves marks on my eye lids. I like a thin line, which this easily gives. If I keep a q-tip close, I am able to "erase" skips in the application process. It does stay on for a good amount of time, once it has dried. Read more
puzzlenutβDecember 1, 2025
Very disappointed. I have used this brand for 20 years and loved it. Then it disappeared. I was so happy to find it again on Amazonβ but it is not the same as the original eyeliner. It does not seem to dry completely no matter how long I wait. Even when it seems set, it immediately transfers to the crease of my eye and smudges the line on the lid! To make matters worse, even tho it smears all ppl over your eyelid it is very difficult to remove. Just not the same eyeliner. Wish it was original formula. I will not buy again. Read more
Liz RomeroβOctober 22, 2025
Eyeliner goes on evenly, color is perfect darkest black, waterproof will not smear. It may run if you put an excessive amount. brush does glide easily, make sure you shake the tube before opening, to mix well. The liquid will not burn if liquid goes inside eye. To remove eyeliner, you may use make up remover or vasoline. Read more