Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil Medium Brown 1 Count

I’ve been using the Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil in Soft Brown for 1 year now, and honestly, it’s one of the best drugstore brow products I’ve ever tried. The Soft Brown shade is absolutely perfect if you have medium to light brown hair – not too warm, not too ashy, and it gives the most natural-looking fill without looking harsh or drawn-on. If you’re looking for an easy-to-use, beginner-friendly brow pencil that delivers natural, tempting results, the Maybelline Total Temptation in Soft Brown is a must-try. Highly recommend! Read more

I absolutely love this eyebrow pencil! I've been using it for years and I was originally buying it from Target and other local stores until they stopped carrying it. Thankfully, I can still find it on Amazon. The formula goes on super smooth, and the blonde shade is perfect—not too light, not too dark. With other brands, I always struggled to find the right tone, but this one is spot on for a natural look. Another feature I really appreciate is the built-in brow brush on the other end. It’s incredibly handy, especially when I’m traveling and want to keep things minimal. Pros: - Smooth application - Perfect natural blonde shade - Built-in brow brush for convenience - Great for travel - Long-time reliable product Cons: - The pencil can break if you twist it up too far—just be careful not to extend it too much This is my go-to brow pencil and I’m so glad I can still get it online. If you're looking for a natural-looking blonde brow pencil that applies easily and travels well, this is it. Highly recommend! Read more

The soft brown Maybelline eyebrow pencil is very nice and affordable; however, I already “subscribe” to the medium brown pencil, but now want to switch to soft brown. A few weeks ago, I wanted an extra eyebrow pencil to have a spare when lever I misplace the one that comes monthly. I also wanted to try a new color. I like the soft brown color, and would love to switch. The soft brown is more expensive right now than the medium brown that I’m buying on my subscription, and I don’t want to keep buying 2 eyebrow pencils a month until my subscription for the medium brown pencils expires. I don’t know how I can tell Amazon to keep my subscription for the eyebrow pencil, but switch to Maybeline’s soft brown color on the next shipment. Can ANYONE TELL ME how to handle this??? Read more

Easy to use, smooth application and stays on all day! Color matches brows perfectly. Tried multiple pencils from other brands and found the perfect match! Read more

I purchased the Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil in Soft Brown, and it has quickly become part of my daily makeup routine. The color is natural and well-balanced, making it easy to define my brows without them looking too dark or harsh. The pencil glides on smoothly and allows for precise application, which makes shaping and filling in brows simple and controlled. I like that it builds easily, so I can keep the look soft for everyday wear or add more definition when needed. It stays in place throughout the day without smudging or fading. Overall, this eyebrow pencil offers great performance at an affordable price. It’s easy to use, dependable, and delivers a polished, natural finish. I’m very happy with this purchase and would recommend it to anyone looking for a reliable brow pencil for everyday use. Read more

This is my favorite eyebrow pencil. I rebuy it every time it runs out. I like how easy it is to apply, and how long it lasts. I can also easily wipe it off if I misapply. It fills in my eyebrow perfectly and looks natural. Read more

Works well. Read more

I stupidly over plucked for years and now it’s too late: they’re never coming back. I can’t afford micro blading so I’m stuck having to draw my brows every day. Pencils with the sharpeners are the worst because the pencil eventually wears down and you eventually lose the sharpener. Other pens snap if you twist them up too high in their chamber thingy and most offer no features that let you apply with realistic detail, but this has a solid strong twist up pen with an angled point that gives you more application approaches. This has been my fake-brows go-to for years and I hope they never discontinue it. But I think they may already have because I can never find it in stores. Amazon is the only place I’ve been able to find it. Read more