NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Liner Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner with Vegan Formula - Milk Chocolate Brown Matte

LOVE this eye liner. Best one I have ever used and the brown color is so pretty on fair skin. I have gotten it in my eyes a couple times and it hasn't hurt at all. It lasts a while if you dont touch it, but if you rub your eyes or anything like that it will come off. It dries super quickly and I typically curl my lashes right after I put it on and it hasn't smudged yet. My only complaint is that the product leaks out in the cap, so when you open it you get eyeliner all over everything. This has only started happening recently, as I have had it for a couple months. Would recommend anyways. Read more

My favorite eyeliner right now. This lasts such a long time! I bought this in May 2025, it’s now January 2026 and there’s still some in the eyeliner but thought it was time to get a new one , I can tell it’s running low. I wear make up and use this maybe 2-3x a week. It’s easy to put on , glides easily and you can use the fine tip to get in those little spots close to your lash line. You can make the line super thin or thick. It stays in place all day and partly the next morning when I forget to wash my face . It doesn’t rub off or smudge . It dries quick enough so I can use my eyelash curler immediately. This doesn’t irritate my eyes. The black color is a deep bold black which I like. Great price especially with how long it lasts, I would’ve gone through several eyeliner pencils at this point. Read more

Nice liner for the price It goes on easily and stays on Its very small pointed brush lets you control how thick you want your application to be The price is amazing when you compare it to so many products out there It’s a great product has good pigmentation and dries quickly It does not irritate my eyes and it’s staying power is good Read more

Excellent fine lash line or thicker Cleopatra lines accomplished with accuracy. Even flow from tip every time. Must be stored vertically with cap upside & shaken before use to maintain flow & get the full quantity inside. No eye irritation & long lasting as well as dries quickly upon application. Contents are less than desired so I always buy 2 at a time. Can't afford to run out if I'm in a hurry. Not convinced its waterproof, but doesn't smudge or smear & stays put, easily removed with water leaving no irritation. Good product from a fussy eye makeup user. Read more

I loved it so much, I bought two of them. They have the most beautiful consistency, it's almost like an ink pen and so you can just draw on your eyeliner is thick or as thin as you want and it looks like professional makeup because you're able to apply it so perfectly and smoothly. It doesn't wear off, but it comes off easily with soap and water, yet it last all day on your skin. I love it. And I love that it's cruelty free! Read more

I love this eyeliner. I just wish it came with a little more. I do pretty heavy black eyeliner so maybe it is just because I use it so often that it seems like it runs out all the time. The tip of the liner is very soft and it glides on very nicely. it's very easy to use and to do fine details with. I wish the cap would stop popping off randomly sometimes. that's something that has happened with multiple eyeliners though, not just this one. i think it's just something weird about the springs in them. I do love the quality of the actual eyeliner. I feel that it sticks to my eye better than a lot of the other ones that I've ever used. It does run if you sweat a lot though, but that's expected. I personally have pretty watery eyes so it can be difficult to keep applying without it kind of getting everywhere. Read more

I LOVE this NYX eyeliner pencil. This is the second one I've bought, and I'm obsessed with it. It has a fine tip that allows for precise lines, but it's also easy to build up the color for thicker lines, and it's a true black. Another thing I love is that it's waterproof, which is a huge plus for me! You can buy this with your eyes closed! Read more

I'm looking for a replacement/dupe for KVD tattoo liner, because I'm oily around the eyes and my eyeliner always smudges. Unfortunately this one does smudge a little on me and after a few hours I have a shadow of product under my eyes, which never happened with KVD. It's not a bad product though, if you aren't oily it would probably be fantastic. Read more