Emma—February 11, 2026✓ Verified purchase
I swear this formula is witchcraft! Applies veryyy smoothly, pigmented, and stays in place all day (even on my waterline!) Not 100% smudgeproof, but definitely doesn’t smudge easily. The applicator shape is perfect, very easy to apply. Will definitely be ordering more. Read more
Cindy P.—February 17, 2026✓ Verified purchase
I am thoroughly impressed by this eyeliner. Has plenty of pigment and just glides on the eyes. The price is right for this eyeliner. It is very soft, long lasting and hasn’t smudged on my eyes since I have been using it. Great product! Read more
Customer—January 24, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Love the ease of this liner. I have difficulty with getting a nice line for wing and this helps tremendously with keeping it straight and precise. Read more
Lauren O—February 5, 2026✓ Verified purchase
I got the blue. Goes on easily over eye shadow and dries quickly. The crayon itself can break off easilty if you click too much. It's a nice vibrant addition to my usual subtle makeup. Read more
⛄LLB—January 26, 2026✓ Verified purchase
The very best eyeliner I've ever worn so easy to apply. Just push the button at the bottom of the pencil to release the pencil from the applicator and draw stays on all day the best ever. Read more
JenS—February 3, 2026✓ Verified purchase
This stuff is the best. The pigment is good. It goes on easily and it does not transfer. I would definitely buy this again. Read more
Customer—February 7, 2026✓ Verified purchase
Great pencil, love how smooth it draws, no skipping or dragging. Beautiful matte black, shows up against eyeshadow. It dries quickly so it doesn't mess up but you also have to work fast if you want to smoke it out. It also wears down quickly so you use it up faster than a traditional pencil liner. I haven't tested the waterproof part but it still shows up clearly and cleanly after 12-16 hrs. Read more
Olli—February 5, 2026✓ Verified purchase
The Epic Inky Stix from NYX impressed me from the very first application. The creamy gel texture glides effortlessly over the skin – no pulling, no scratching, just a precise, even line. I find the twist-up mechanism particularly convenient: no sharpening, no product waste, simply twist it up and go. The color payoff is intense and rich, perfect for a defined eyeliner look. I tested it for both a classic wing and a slightly softer smoky liner, and it worked perfectly in both cases. You have a few seconds to blend it before it dries – and after that, it's completely smudge-proof. No smearing, no transfer, even after a long day. What I especially like: It's precise enough for fine lines, but at the same time creamy enough to use as a kohl pencil on the lower lash line without irritating the eyes. For me, it's a great all-rounder if you're looking for a reliable, easy-to-use eyeliner that's suitable for both everyday looks and more dramatic styles. Read more